The Historic And Sometimes Violent Giants/Dodgers Rivalry On Center Stage In The 2021 NLDS

The Los Angeles Dodgers will take on the San Francisco Giants in what could be the most epic playoff battle in postseason history. The rivalry dates back to 1889 when the Dodgers played in Brooklyn while the Giants were at the Polo Grounds in Manhatten.

The two teams were bitter against each other not only because of location but because the Giants fans were upper-class elite. In contrast, the Dodgers fans were often blue-collar and working-class atmosphere.

A personal feud between Dodgers owner Charles Ebbets and Giants manager John McGraw heated the battle, causing incidents on both sides in the early 1900s. Players on either team were involved in on and off-the-field situations, which inflamed fans to despise each other.

Fatal cases have occurred between fans in 1938 and 2003. A Giants fan Mark Antenorcruz was shot and killed in the Los Angeles Dodgers parking lot following a dispute over the teams.

In 2011, Bryan Stow was left handicapped after fighting with Dodgers fans in a Los Angeles parking lot. Stow has shown some improvement but will never be the same.

San Francisco Giants fan, Bryan Stow, who was attacked at Dodger Stadium.

San Francisco Giants fan, Bryan Stow, who was attacked at Dodger Stadium.

In 2013, Dodgers fan Jonathan Denver was stabbed to death six blocks from Oracle Park. He was found wearing Dodgers gear after a night game. Nobody was charged as it was unknown if the attacker (Michael Montgomery) was using self-defense. Also, there was insufficient evidence to criminally charge Montgomery.

Once, Dodgers manager Joe Torre described how he felt threatened as a fan growing up in Brooklyn and wasn't a fan of the Giants.

"As a kid growing up, you didn't like them," Torre said on WFAN radio in New York before the hiring was announced. "As a player, to me, the Dodgers were the Yankees of the National League because ... you either loved them or you hated them."

The two teams moved after the 1957 season when Dodgers owner Walter O'Malley decided to move to Los Angeles. O'Malley convinced Giants owner Horace Stoneham to do the same to keep the teams embroiled in competition.

The move didn't end the disdain for each other. In 1965, Juan Marichal hit Dodgers catcher John Roseboro in the head with a bat.

The entanglement all started when Marichal buzzed hitter Maury Wills with a pitch. Sandy Koufax retaliated with a fastball over Willie Mays' head. Marichal went after Ron Fairly with an inside fastball that sent him sprawling. Home plate umpire Shag Crawford then issued a warning to both teams.

In response, Roseboro didn't want Marichal to get away with being the last player to retaliate. When Marichal was up in the bottom of the third, an inside pitch from Koufax was dropped by Roseboro. He got behind Marichal to pick the ball up and threw it hard behind Marichal's ear and close to his face.

Marichal then turned to Roseboro as expletives were exchanged. As Roseboro stepped toward Marichal, who raised his bat and slammed it into Roseboro's head. Marichal explained what transpired and why he hit Roseboro in the head.

Roseboro-Marichal Incident

Roseboro-Marichal Incident

"I was afraid he was going to hit me with his mask, so I hit him with my bat," Marichal said in an apology issued the next day.

Each team's bench cleared, and fights ensued. In the end, Marichal was ejected and suspended for eight games. He missed ten in total due to double-headers and was fined $1,750 ($15,00 today). Roseboro left the game to get stitched up (14 stitches) and miss the next two contests.

In 2014, Madison Bumgarner and Yasiel Puig got in an exchange after Puig flipped his bat when he hit a home run off Bumgarner. Then, Max Muncy hit a homer off Bumgarner that landed in McCovey Cove. Muncy watched it fly off the bat, and Bumgarner yelled insults. Muncy retorted: "If you don't like it, you can go get it out of the ocean!".

Iconic players have retired instead of continuing to play baseball on the other team. Jackie Robinson retired after being traded in 1956 to the Giants. Willie Mays refused to sign with the Dodgers after the 1972 season and was traded to the Mets.

As for the team series and its, 131 year history will be the first time the Giants and Dodgers meet in the postseason. The overall head-to-head battle while in New York lent itself to the Giants 721-670-17 throughout 68-years. However, the tables have turned since the move to California. The Dodgers have a 675-647 lead. Since 2010, the series has been very close as the Giants have a 109-106 victory edge. This season, San Francisco leads 10-9 in games played.

There have many playoff races decided by the fortunate or misfortunate events by either team. In 1951, Bobby Thompson hit the pennant-winning home run off Ralph Branca in the 'Shot Heard Round the World'.

In 1982, Joe Morgan hit a three-run homer knocking out the Dodgers from playoff contention after eliminating the Giants just a few games prior.

Los Angeles returned the favor when Mike Piazza and crew destroyed San Francisco 12-1 on the season's final day. The loss allowed the Braves to enter the playoffs and eliminated the 103-win Giants.

In 2001, San Francisco finished two games behind Arizona even though Barry Bonds hit 73 home runs. This is mainly due to Los Angeles taking two of three games against the Giants in the season's final series.

Looking at both teams heading into the playoffs, more than wins and losses barely keep these teams apart. For instance, the graph below demonstrates how close they are, courtesy of MLB.com.

Picture1.jpg

The first game between these two historic teams begins on Friday at Oracle Park at 6:37 p.m. Game 2 will start at 6:07 p.m. on Saturday. Monday, the series will resume in Los Angeles.

Logan Webb will receive the start, while Kevin Gausman will start in the second game. Walker Buehler will battle Webb and face the Giants for the seventh time this season.

SF Giants vs LA Dodgers CLASH OF THE SEASON - Series Preview

ERIK.PNG

Amazingly, as we enter September and prepare for the biggest series of the season in the NL West, the Los Angeles Dodgers and San Francisco Giants not only have the exact same record at this point in the season, but they also are also evenly matched with an 8-8 record against each other. The only metric that may be in the Dodgers favor at this point is momentum, as they have been scorching hot while the Giants just salvaged one game in the last 2 series - a 3-game series in Atlanta and a 4-game series against the Brewers in San Francisco.

That is why tonight’s game is so vital, as who ever wins will take sole possession of first place and immediately take the momentum into the Game 2. This will by no means be a cakewalk for either club and if Dodgers fans assume it will be, they should remember the Dodgers losing multiple games recently against teams like the Colorado Rockies and the Los Angeles Angels. In baseball, it’s never easy, and a team like the Giants - even when they are having a terrible season which is clearly not this year - always step up and give the Dodgers everything they want. Expect no different in this series.

Friday, September 3rd

Tonight’s matchup begins with David Price for the Dodgers against Anthony Desclafani for the Giants. Price is no longer an elite starting pitcher but he should not be underestimated either. His ERA is solid at 4.37 this season in 33 appearances, only 11 of which were starts. In just his starts, he has held opposing hitters to a .234 batting average. His ERA is also very solid except for during the 1st inning, where he has a 5.73 ERA. If the Giants plan to do damage against Price, the first inning could be his most susceptible based on his performance so far this year.

Anthony Desclafani has been lights out for the Giants for a large part of the season. However, there is one team he has consistently struggled against. You guessed it - the Los Angeles Dodgers. In five starts against the Dodgers, he has a 9.43 ERA, allowing 6 home runs in 21 innings along with 31 hits and 12 walks. This is something that can’t be ignored going into this series. However, the overall pictures has been solid for Desclafani, as he has an 11-6 record with a 3.38 ERA and should have probably been an All Star after a stellar first half, but was unfortunately snubbed from the roster.

Saturday, September 4th

Unfortunately, another problem the Giants have coming into this series is a lack of reliable starting arms and the starter for Saturday is currently TBD. Both Johnny Cueto and Alex Wood are unavailable with Wood testing positive for Covid-19 and Cueto missing a start with illness then getting lit up the next day when he tried to pitch. The Dodgers will try to take advantage of this with the Giants possibly using Jose Quintana, who did not have a good year with the Angels but did pitch well in his Giants debut, or Sammy Long, who has looked solid lately but certainly isn’t going to be favored over the Dodgers starter, Julio Urias.

Urias only leads the entire league in wins and after a couple of rough outings, he put together his best month of the season in August, going 3-0 with a 1.38 ERA. His last 3 outings against San Francisco have been solid and the Dodgers should be favorites in Game 2, which is another reason why Game 1 is so vital as the Giants will have Anthony Desclafani going, at least one healthy arm that has been reliable for them this year (albeit not against the Dodgers).

Sunday, September 5th

The Giants have not announced their pitcher for Sunday either, but no matter who they throw out there, the Dodgers will be favorites with Walker Buehler, the possible Cy Young Award winner this year, taking the hill. He is 13-2 with a 2.05 ERA and is clearly one of the best pitchers in the game today. With proper rest, neither Kevin Gausman nor Logan Webb would be available for this series. Gausman should be set to start Monday against the Rockies unless he’s bumped up to Sunday. Otherwise, the Giants will have to rely on a combination of their bullpen and again, Quintana or Long, to compete against Buehler. Again, Game 1 is absolutely critical.