An MLB season lasts 162 games and every one of them count. If there’s one lesson that has been taught over and over throughout baseball history, teams need to get the pedal the metal all the way up until a playoff spot or division title has been mathematically guaranteed. Without that, it doesn’t matter how big of a lead your team has entering September. In today’s video, we’ll take a look at the Top 10 most epic and painful team collapses in MLB history. There are teams that had great seasons up until that final home stretch when everything completely fell apart and when that happens, there’s almost always another team getting hot just at the right time to take that playoff spot from them.
Before I get into the main list, I have 2 honorable mentions – or should I say dishonorable mentions - that didn’t quite make the list.
Honorable Mention #1 – the 1951 Brooklyn Dodgers, who had a 13 ½ game lead at one point in the season, but a red-hot Giants team caught them, forcing a 3-game playoff that led to Bobby Thomson’s shot heard round the world. The fact that this didn’t make my Top 10 tells you what kind of collapses we’re about to talk about.
Honorable Mention #2 – The 2021 New York Mets, who were the first team to spend over 100 days in first place and still finish with a losing record. Their collapse was a bit more gradual and not a complete last minute meltdown, which is why they’re not in the Top 10.
Now, let’s get started with the Top 10.
#10 The 1987 Toronto Blue Jays
In 1987, the Toronto Blue Jays looked prime to win with a team loaded with stars like Fred McGriff, George Bell, Jesse Barfield and even a young Cecil Fielder. Their pitching was stacked with names like Jimmy Key, Dave Stieb and closer Tom Henke. On June 13th, they were 32-20, sitting in first place in the A.L. East. They never took a massive lead in the division and in fact were competing with the Tigers for the division crown, but after they won 2 out of 3 against them in a late September series – and by late I mean around September 27th, it appeared that the division belonged to the Jays. They were up by 3 ½ games with just 7 to play when the Jays completely lost it. They were swept by the Brewers, then had one final 3-game series with the Tigers in which they were again swept, losing each game by 1 run. The Blue Jays lost 7 consecutive games to finish the season and ended up losing the division to the Tigers, who won their final 4 games to clinch the championship and send the Blue Jays home.
#9 The 1934 New York Giants
The 1934 St. Louis Cardinals caught the 1934 Giants against all odds
The 1934 Giants were absolutely stacked. They had three future Hall-of-Famers, Mel Ott, Bill Terry and Travis Jackson, in their starting lineup. The rotation included two pitchers who won over 20 games that season in Hal Schumacher and another Hall-of-Famer, Carl Hubbell. The team spent the vast majority of the season in first place and had a 7-game lead on September 6th. They struggled a bit during the next week, but with just 14 games left to play, still held a 5 ½ game lead over the St. Louis Cardinals. Then, the two teams met in a 3-game series and the Cardinals won 2 out of 3. Led by the powerful slugger Ripper Collins and their Ace Pitcher, Dizzy Dean, the Cardinals continued to stay hot, slowly gaining on the Giants. Still, with five games left in the season, the Giants were up by the three games and their only remaining games were against two bottom feeders in the league at the time, the Dodgers and Phillies. The Cardinals needed to win just about every game the rest of the way and hope that the Giants would somehow lose every one of their five remaining games. That’s exactly what happened. The Giants lost their final five games of the season and the Cardinals swept the Reds to propel them into first place, making the Giants the first team in MLB history to blow a 7-game lead in September.
#8 The 2007 New York Mets
The Mets are a team that have some of the most unbelievable comebacks in baseball history but also a team known for massive late-season collapses. The 2021 Mets know something about collapsing as they spent more than 100 days in first place yet still finished with a losing record. Neverthelss,they got nothing on the 2007 Mets. After a rough loss in the 2006 playoffs, the Mets entered 2007 motivated and ready, with a wealth of talent that included Carlos Delgado, Jose Reyes, David Wright, Carlos Beltran, Tom Glavine and Billy Wagner. They won the first four games of the year and after 14 games, were 11-3. The domination continued throughout the season and on September 12th, the Mets held a 7 game lead in the division with the best record in the league. With 17 games left in the season, the playoffs seemed to be in the bag. Then, they lost a game by 1 run against the Phillies. Then, they lost another, this time by 2 runs. Then they lost another, by 4 runs. Then, they were blown, losing by 8 runs. What the hell was going on? The losing streak reached 5 games before they finally won a game. Despite the skid,The Mets had held such a strong lead in the division that with 7 games to go, they were still up by 2 ½ games. They had favorable matchups against two teams at the very bottom of the division - the Florida Marlins and Washington Nationals along with one make-up game against the 73-82 Cardinals. They were swept by the Nationals and lost the makeup game to the Cardinals. After splitting the first two games with the Marlins, the Mets had to win Game 3 in order to prevent The Phillies, who won 4 of their last 5, to take the division. Tom Glavine could only get one batter out and the Marlins pounded the Mets 8-1. They lost the division and the incredibly hot Colorado Rockies overtook them for the Wild Card Spot. The Mets somehow blew a 7-game division lead with 17 games left and didn’t even get a wild card spot as consolation.
#7 The 1962 Los Angeles Dodgers
Newspaper Clipping from October 1st, 1962 reporting on the Dodgers & Giants Pennant Race
Coming in at #7 on my list of the worst late season collapses in MLB history is going to be the 1962 Los Angeles Dodgers. This is a team that was having an absolute dream of a season, entering into September with an 88-47 record, then going on a 7 game winning streak to apparently solidify their place as the #1 team in the National League. Only The Giants could dream of catching them, but they were 4 games back with just a week left to go in the season. The Dodgers were running on all cylinders, led by elite starters Don Drysdale and and Sandy Koufax. They had a chance to clinch the pennant during a 3-game series against the expansion Houston Colt 51s, but lost 2 out of 3. Then, all they had to do was manage one win during a 3-game series against the St. Louis Cardinals. They were swept. Miraculously, the Giants caught the Dodgers and both teams were tied with a 101-61 record at the end of 162 games. The teams played a 3-game series to determine the pennant, just as they had done in 1951. And just like in 1951, the series went to a third game with the Dodgers looking strong late in the game. They had a 4-2 lead going to the Top of the 9th inning when the Dodgers imploded. Four walks, a wild pitch and an error later, the Giants had taken a 6-4 lead. They went on to win the game by that score, winning their first pennant in San Francisco. The Dodgers lost 12 of their last 16 games to blow the pennant in ‘62.
#6 The 1969 Chicago Cubs
A black cat prances around in front of the 1969 Cubs dugout
It was the historic 1969 season, the first season of division play and the Chicago Cubs looked destined to make a push for their first World Series championship since 1908. At the All-Star Break they had an incredibly impressive 61-37 record with a 5 game lead over the 2nd place Mets. By mid-August, that lead had increased to nine games. On September 2nd, they were 32 games over .500, led by superstars like Billy Williams, Fergie Jenkins, Ron Santo and, of course, Ernie Banks. Then, the Mets suddenly caught fire, going on a 10-game winning streak. The Cubs on the other hand, who hadn’t lost more than 4 in a row all season long, lost 8 straight. Still, the Cubs held on a lead in the division. Then, on a September 9th game between the two teams, a black cat showed up in front of the Cubs dugout and pranced back and forth a couple times before running off. Whether one believes in the supernatural or not, this couldn’t be a good sign. Sure enough, the Cubs continued to fall apart and the Mets kept winning. New York went 38-11 and finish out the season and not only won the division, but won it by an absolutely insane 8 games, despite being back by 9 games in mid-August. The Cubs lost 18 of their final 26 games to finish off the collapse. This, of course, was part of the story for the 1969 Miracle Mets, who went on the win the World Series.
#5 The 2009 Detroit Tigers
On May 10th, 2009, The Detroit Tigers won a baseball game in Cleveland, which propelled them into first place in the American League Central. Nearly 4 months later, entering into September, they had never relinquished that first place spot and continued to look amazing, winning 6 consecutive games to start the month. They entered into a series against the last place Royals with a strong 7 game lead over the Twins. Undoubtedly, fans were preparing for a World Series push in October. This was when everything began to fall apart. The Tigers were swept by Kansas City and went on to lose 9 out of 12 games. The Twins, meanwhile, were heating up, and at one point in September, won 11 out of 12. On September 29th, the teams met up in a 4-game series. If The Tigers could win 3 out of 4, they would clinch. The series ended up in a 2-2 split. Still, The Tigers held a 2-game lead in the division with both teams entering the final 3-game series of the season. If The Tigers could win one game out of the 3 and the Twins lose just one out of 3, Detroit would clinch. The Twins did what they had to and swept the Royals. Meanwhile, the Tigers lost game one against the White Sox in a game full of ejections and hit by pitches. Their superstar Miguel Cabrera decided it was good night to go hang out and get drunk with some White Sox players. He got into an altercation with his wife and had to be picked up at the police station by the Tigers GM Dave Dombrowski. Needless to say, he didn’t have his best game, going 0-4 as the Tigers lost 8-0. They won the last game of the year, but with the Twins sweep of the Royals, the teams ended the 162-game season tied, necessitating a 163rd game to determine the division winner. In an insane game that went 12 innings, the Tigers blundered several opportunities to win the game and in end, the Twins were victorious, knocking the Tigers out of the playoffs on October 4th. It was an absolutely unbelievable meltdown and to this day, one of the most epic collapses in MLB History.
#4 The 1978 Boston Red Sox
Coming up next is the 1978 Boston Red Sox, a team loaded with talent. A few names you might recognize include Dennis Eckersley, Luis Tiant, Carlton Fisk, Jim Rice, Fred Lynn, Dwight Evans and Carl Yastrzemski. The team got off to a red-hot start, winning 19 of their first 30 games and cementing themselves into first place. By June, they were 45-19 and 7 games ahead of the Yankees. Come September 1st, the Red Sox were on a 6-game wining streak, holding a 6 ½ game lead in the division with a month to go. Then, they entered into a rough patch, losing 5 out of 7 games. That’s when the 2nd place Yankees came to town for a 4-game series. If the Red Sox could just manage a split, any hope the Yankees had at that point could be put to bed. Instead, the Yankees swept the series and could smell first place, sitting just 3 ½ games back. The Red Sox continued to fall, losing 5 of the next 6. This epic collapse allowed the Yankees to tie for the division lead at the end of the year, forcing a one-game playoff. During this game, the Red Sox had a 2-0 lead entering into the 7th inning. It was looking like maybe they could pull through after all. That’s when Bucky Dent came to the plate. Incredibly, against all the odds, the Yankees came back from 6 ½ games back in September to win the game and the division.
#3 The 1995 California Angels
Lee Smith, closer for the 1995 California Angels
By 1995, Angels fans had gotten used to late-season collapses. It had happened multiple times in the 80’s, and when they did make the playoffs, things got even more painful. However, the 1995 California Angels looked like a Team of Destiny. They had a powerful rotation anchored by Mark Langston and Chucky Finley to go along with an incredibly talented lineup featuring the likes of J.T. Snow, Chili Davis, Jim Edmonds and Tim Salmon. They even had a future Hall-of-Famer as their closer with Lee Smith. Unsurprisingly, the Angels dominated the league for months, building an 11-game lead by early August. Suddenly, the Seattle Mariners received a massive jumpstart from the return of Ken Griffey Jr. who had been injured since May. He made his return on August 15th and beginning on the very next day, the Angels suddenly lost it, losing 21 of 25 games. Nevertheless, their lead was so strong it seemed insurmountable and with just two weeks left in the season, they somehow still maintained a 6-game lead. Then they lost 9 more in a row. In an absolutely incredible turn of events, the Seattle Mariners came back from 11 games back in August to tie the Angels for the division lead at the end of the season, forcing a one-game playoff. In that game, the Mariners sent the intimidating future Hall-of-Famer Randy Johnson to the mound. He threw 150 pitches to seal the deal, defeating the Angels 9-1 and ending their playoff hopes. The Angels were 66-41 on August 20th with a 12 ½ game lead over the Mariners and went 12-44 the rest of the way, including two 9-game losing streaks. It was one of the most monumental meltdowns ever.
#2 The 2011 Boston Red Sox and Atlanta Braves
I’m going to cheat a little and put two in one since this was an epic dual collapse that the baseball world witnessed in 2011. Consider this 2a and 2b. The Atlanta Braves were essentially a lock to make the playoffs, holding a 8 ½ game lead over the Cardinals for the Wild Card on September 1st. Meanwhile, in the American League, the Red Sox had a 9 game lead for the Wild Card just in case they didn’t win the division, which they led by a game over the Yankees. The tailspin began for the Braves on September 2nd, as they began a 3-game series against the Dodgers. They lost the series 2-1. No big deal, right? Then they were swept by the Phillies in a series that included a 9-0 shutout. The bullpen, which had been lights out all season led by closer Craig Kimbrell, began to struggle and the offense went cold. The Cardinals had gotten red-hot and were gaining ground. The two teams met on September 9th for a 3-game series and the Braves were swept. By the end of the season, the Cards were hot on their trail and won 4 of their last 5 games to overtake the Braves, who lost 5 consecutive games to end the season.
During this monumental meltdown, the Red Sox weren’t faring much better, as they went 7-20 in the month of September, giving up the division to the Yankees. The Wild Card was in danger too, but a Rays loss and Red Sox win on the last day of the season would clinch it. It seemed as everything was going to work out as the Yankees were beating the Rays 7-0 in the 8th inning and the Red Sox led the Orioles in the bottom of the 9th with Jonathan Papelbon ready to close it out. Then, in a horrifying turn of events for Red Sox fans, the Orioles rallied, scoring 6 runs in the 8th and another in the 9th to tie the game. Up stepped Evan Longoria in the 12th inning to cap off the most epic dual collapse in MLB history.
1. The 1964 Philadelphia Phillies
1964 World Series Phillies Ticket
They were one of the most dominant young teams to ever take the field for the majority of 1964, led by Dick Allen, Johnny Callison and 19-game winner Jim Bunning. They were 47-28 at the All Star Break, and didn’t slow down from there, building a 6 ½ game first place lead by September 20th. That’s right – they had a 6 ½ lead on September 20th with just 12 games left in the season. The team literally began to print World Series tickets and Sports Illustrated held a photo shoot with the team for the cover of their World Series edition. There were two teams tied for 2nd place – the Reds and Cardinals, both 6 ½ back. As fate would have it, the Phillies schedule had them playing both teams down the stretch. First, they took on the Reds in a 3 game series that began on September 21st. They were swept. At the time, it wasn’t that big of a deal as they still held a 3 ½ game lead with about a week to go. Luckily, they had a fairly easy 4-game series against the middle-of-the-road Milwaukee Braves. They were swept again, bringing them to a 3-game series against the Cardinals, who smelled blood. The shell-shocked Phillies were once again swept, bringing their overall losing streak to 10 games. The Cardinals took over first place and won the pennant by a single game in what had to be the most epic and unexpected collapse in the history of the game. The team completely fell apart defensively and offensively while the manager Gene Mauch burned out his two best starters by starting them over and over during the losing streak. There have been many horrible collapses in MLB history, but the 1964 Phillies come in at #1 on my list.