The Top 15 MLB UNDRAFTED Free Agents of All Time

Since the inception of the MLB Draft, there have been many great players not considered to be very big prospects who were taken extremely low yet went on to have elite MLB careers. Players not taken in the first few rounds generally have a much tougher path to the big leagues and have to really impress in the Minor Leagues. Nevertheless, there have been some players such as Mike Piazza, who was taken as the 1,390th overall pick, who overcame being picked low in the draft and went on to become Hall of Famers. Still, there are many other players who have to take an even tougher path to baseball’s highest level – and for these players, the odds of even making it the big leagues – much less becoming an impact player - are even longer. These are players who were never drafted at all, despite being available in an MLB Draft. These players have to somehow get the attention of an MLB team with the help of an agent or by playing in the independent leagues, hoping to get signed as an undrafted free agent, giving them an opportunity to play in an affiliated minor league system. Even if this happens, the undrafted free agent is rarely considered anything more than a roster filler in the minors. They have to play extremely well in order to get the attention of the big league front office and finally be considered a realistic prospect.

Today, we will be ranking the Top 15 Best MLB Undrafted Free Agents of all time – these players were able to play well enough in the minors to get an opportunity in the big leagues and they took full advantage of it. As a side note, only players who were eligible for the first year MLB draft and were not drafted will be included – so this list will not include players such as Larry Walker and Edgar Martinez, who were signed as international free agents and were not eligible for the draft. Also, players were were drafted after High School but did not sign in order to go college, then later went undrafted after college are eligible for this list. So, let’s get into it, starting with 5 honorable mentions:

Honorable Mentions:

Kirby Yates – an active relief pitcher who led the National League with 41 saves in 2019

Kevin Millar – a 2004 World Series Champion with the Red Sox who hit 170 career home runs

Jim Leyrtiz – a two-time World Series champ with the Yankees who had an 11-year big league career

Dan Gladden – who won two rings with the Twins and retired with over 1,200 hits

Ken Hill – one of the best pitchers in the game for the Expos during the strike-shortened 1994 season

Now, let’s get into the Top 15

#15 Bernard Gilkey – OF (21.6 WAR)

First up is a classic name from the St. Louis Cardinals lineup of the early 90’s, Bernard Gilkey. Gilkey graduated from University City High School in 1984 but went completely undrafted. He signed as an undrafted free agent with the Cardinals and displayed amazing speed with a solid bat that only improved as he moved up through the minors. He stole 56 bases in Single A in ‘88 and another 53 in Double A in ‘89, leading the league. After 6 long years in the Minors, Gilkey was promoted and by 1991, was in the Opening Day lineup. He consistently hit around .300 for St. Louis until he was traded to the Mets, where in 1996 he had his best year, driving in 117 runs with a .317 batting average and 30 home runs. Unfortunately, he was snubbed from the ‘96 All Star Team. He finished his career with a .275 average and 118 homers.

#14 Esteban Loaiza – P (22.7 WAR)

Up next is a 14-year big league pitcher who started the 2003 All-Star Game – Esteban Loaiza. Loaiza was ready to enter professional baseball after a stellar High School career at Mar Vista High, but sadly went completely undrafted. Later, he was able to sign with the Pirates and entered their Minor League system in 1991, going 5-1 with a 2.26 ERA in Rookie Ball. He continued to impress as he moved up through the minors and in 1995, he made the team out of Spring Training and was put into the starting rotation. Loaiza was a serviceable big league arm for years with the Pirates, Rangers and Blue Jays until everything clicked in 2003 with the White Sox, when he went 21-9 with a 2.9 ERA and league-leading 207 strikeouts. He finished second in the Cy Young voting to Roy Halladay and started the All Star Game. He made a second All Star team in 2004, although he never repeated that amazing 2003 season.

#13 John Montefusco – P (19.9 WAR)

John “The Count” of Montefusco was a staple in the San Francisco Giants rotation during the 1970’s. He attended Brookdale Community College and went completely undrafted in 1972. Fortunately, he was able to sign a contract with the Giants and dazzled in the minor leagues, going 9-2 with a 2.17 ERA and a 9.5 per 9 strikeout ratio. He made his big league debut in 1974 and became a regular by ‘75, when he won the Rookie of the Year award and finished 4th in the Cy Young voting. In 1976, he threw a no-hitter against the Braves, which was the last Giants no-hitter up until 2009 when Jonathan Sanchez finally threw another one. Montefusco later pitched for the Braves, Padres and Yankees, finishing his career with a 90-83 record.

#12 Tommy Herr – 2B (23.6 WAR)

Next up is Tommy Herr, a fan favorite for many years in St. Louis who played in three separate World Series for St. Louis, helping them win one in 1982. He attended the University of Delaware and went undrafted in 1974. Luckily, he caught on with the Cardinals, signing for a $10,000 bonus, and began his Minor League career ‘75. He showed an amazing ability to hit for average and get on base while playing nearly flawless defense. In 1977, he led his Single A league with 156 hits and he also stole an incredible 50 bases. In 1979, he made his big league debut and by the 1980’s, became a regular in the lineup. His best season came in 1985 when he made the All Star Team and drove in 110 runs with a .302 average. He also stole 31 bases, being thrown out only 3 times. Herr retired with the best fielding percentage in the history of MLB for second basemen despite never winning a Gold Glove.

#11 Mike Bordick – IF (26.8 WAR)

A familiar name to Oakland A’s fans of the early 90’s, Mike Bordick played college ball at the University of Maine but no team picked his name during the 1985 MLB Draft. He went on to play in the Cap Cod League, where A’s scout J.P. Ricciardi, who went on to become the Blue Jays GM and now works in the Giants front office, noticed Bordick and signed him to play in the A’s organization. Although his stats were nothing spectacular, he showed incredible work ethic and knew how to work the count and get on base. He worked his way up through the minors and made his MLB debut in 1990. By ‘92, he was an everyday player and hit .300 with 151 hits and 40 walks. By 2000, he developed some power, crushing 20 home runs for the Mets and Orioles and making the All Star Team. He finished his career with an impressive 26.8 WAR.

#10 Danny Darwin – P (39.8 WAR)

Coming in at #10 is Danny Darwin, a starting pitcher and reliever who had a 21-year big league career. He pitched at Grayson County College in Texas and was completely overlooked in the draft. In May of 1976, he signed with the Rangers and quickly impressed in the Minors, going 13-4 with a 2.51 ERA in 1977. He was promoted to Triple A in 1978 and showed amazing strikeout ability, earning a call-up to the big leagues. He had his first full MLB season in 1980 and impressed, going 13-4 with a 2.63 ERA. From there, Darwin would become a solid MLB arm for two decades, as a reliever and starter, pitching for 8 separate teams. In 1990 with the Astros, he led the league with a 2.21 ERA. He pitched for the Giants from 1997 to 1998, retiring with nearly 2,000 career strikeouts and an extremely impressive 39.8 WAR.

#9 Tom Candiotti – P (41.4 WAR)

Up next is the Candy Man, Tom Candiotti, a knuckleballer who had a 16-year big league career. He pitched out of St. Mary’s College of California for four years, but was never drafted. He was able to catch on with an independent league team in British Columbia, Canada called the Victoria Mussels after attending a try-out in 1979. With no place to live, no money, and no car, Candiotti went 5-1 for the Mussels, sometimes sleeping on the field in a sleeping bag after the game. He pitched well enough to be sold to the Kansas City Royals, but later ended up in the Brewers organization. He pitched well in the minors but had a major setback when he underwent Tommy John Surgery. Candiotti came back strong, however and threw a shutout during his initial call-up to the big leagues in 1983. As a knuckler, he had great stamina and later with the Indians in 1986, led the league with 17 complete games. Candiotti was also a mainstay in the Dodgers rotation for several years in the 90’s. He retired with a 151-164 record and over 1,700 strikeouts.

#8 Larry Bowa – SS (22.8 WAR)

Up next is a player who many now know as an MLB coach and Manager – Larry Bowa. Long before his managerial career, Bowa was a High School kid who tried out for the baseball team and was cut – every single year. Fortunately, he continued to practice and did make his college team at Sacramento City College. He became a strong player there and a scout from the Phillies went to check him out, but he was ejected early in the game for arguing with the umpire. The kid definitely had a future as a manager. As it turned out, no team drafted him. However, the Phillies continued to keep an eye on him as he played in a winter league, showing signs of defensive brilliance and a strong bat. He was eventually offered a contract that included a $2,000 bonus. It turned out to be a wise decision as Bowa hit well in the minors and went on to have an incredible rookie year for the Phillies in 1970. He finished 3rd in the Rookie of the Year voting and went on to make 5 All Star teams and take home 2 Gold Gloves. He hit .316 in the 1980 World Series, helping bring a ring to Philadelphia. He later went on to win the Manager of the Year Award for the Phillies in 2001.

#7 Kevin Mitchell – OF (29.2 WAR)

Coming in appropriately at #7 is my favorite player growing up in the late 80’s, Kevin Mitchell, who blasted 234 career home runs and also made one of the most famous catches in MLB history with this barehanded snag. Long before that, Mitchell’s parents separated when he was two years old. He was raised by his grandmother in a rough neighborhood where he sometimes ran with the wrong crowds, getting involved in gang activity. He struggled in school and never even played High School baseball, but did have a talent for the game thanks largely to his grandma encouraging him to practice baseball, even though he preferred football and boxing. In 1980, a friend of Mitchell’s took him to an open New York Mets tryout and Mitchell displayed incredible power, impressing the scouts, who signed him to a contract for $600 a month to enter into their minor league system. He immediately stood out, hitting .335 with 7 homers in Rookie Ball. Step by step, he ascended through the system and made it to the Major Leagues by 1984. In 1986, his pinch-hit single kept the Mets alive in the World Series and was allowed them to make one of the most dramatic comebacks in baseball history. However, he became an absolute superstar later with the San Francisco Giants, crushing 47 home runs in 1989 and taking home the N.L MVP and a Silver Slugger Award. Mitchell’s career was not always smooth sailing and there are some wild stories about some of his off-the-field antics, but for being an undrafted free agent, he had an incredible career, crushing 234 career homers with a .284 batting average.

#6 Brian Downing – C/OF (51.5 WAR)

Brian Downing, who played Major League Baseball for 20 years and collected over 2,000 hits, was not only an undrafted free agent, but was also cut from his High School teams multiple times. He attended Cyprus College after graduating High School and decided to try out for baseball, but only made the team as the official bullpen catcher. Most people would have given up on their baseball career by this point, but Downing decided to make one last effort and attended a Chicago White Sox open try-out in 1969 and fortunately for Downing, a scout named Bill Lentini saw some potential and offered him a contract. Downing was solid in the minors, hitting .278 with 15 homers in Double A. He made it to the big leagues by 1973, and despite a slow start in MLB, he eventually became a regular in the lineup. During the 1977-78 offseason, he was traded to the Angels and found his comfort zone there. Downing crushed 28 home runs in 1978 and was eventually moved from catcher to outfield. He hit at least 19 home runs for 7 straight seasons and became a fan favorite in Anaheim. He retired with 275 homers and one All Star selection. He also worked an impressive 1,197 walks in his career, giving him a .370 career on-base-percentage. His 51.5 WAR is better than Hall of Famers Kirby Puckett and Orlando Cepeda.

#5 Bobby Bonilla – 3B/OF (30.2 WAR)

An absolute superstar from the late 80’s and early 90’s, Bobby Bonilla is another player who was incredibly never drafted. He did play baseball in High School and graduated in 1981, but went unselected in the draft. He decided to pursue a degree in Computer Science but happened to attend a baseball camp where he was spotted by Pirates scout and future GM Syd Thrift. He played well in the Minors for several years but had a major injury setback with a broken leg, then was claimed in the Rule 5 Draft by the White Sox before he could make his big league debut. The White Sox promoted him in 1986 and he hit .269 with a couple homers before the Pirates reacquired him. In 1987, he showed real promise by hitting .300 with 15 homers. Then, in 1988, everything came together as Bonilla crushed 24 homers with 100 runs driven in. From there, he made 4 consecutive All Star Teams and finished 2nd for the MVP in 1990 with 32 bombs and 120 RBIs. Later, he made two more All Star Teams with the Mets and hit .297 with the Marlins in 1997, helping them win their first World Series. He may be best known now for Bobby Bonilla Day, the annual day when the Mets have to pay Bonilla over a million dollars as part of his 2000 deferred salary – a payment that will continue until 2035.

#4 Dan Quisenberry – P (24.6 WAR)

For a few years, Dan Quisenberry was by far the best relief pitcher in all of baseball. He was encouraged by his stepfather to play the game and was a solid arm in High School, but was not a serious prospect. Later, he was the team’s MVP at Orange Coast College before transferring to La Verne, a Division III baseball program. Quisenberry’s name was never called at the MLB Draft, but he was able to sign with the Royals as an undrafted free agent and absolutely dazzled in the minors, with an even 1 ERA in in 1976. In Double A in 1977, he had a 1.34 ERA in 33 appearances. He had fantastic control and great stuff but could not overpower hitters, and it showed in Triple A when his ERA shot up to 3.6. Royals manager Jim Frey suggested he learn to pitch submarine style in order to keep hitters off balance. This worked wonders for Quisenberry, who quickly mastered the new style and in his first full MLB season in 1980, led the league with 33 saves. In ‘81, he had a 1.73 ERA, kicking off 7 consecutive seasons with an ERA under 3. He led the league in saves for four straight seasons, maxing out at 45, an MLB record, in 1983. He won the Rolaids Relief Pitcher of the Year award 5 times, finishing in the Top 5 for the Cy Young each of those seasons. His reign of complete domination ended around 1985, but he was still solid for several years out of the Royals bullpen. He ended up in St. Louis, where he had a nice year in 1989 with a 2.64 ERA in 63 appearances. He ended his career with 244 saves, and many fans believe he deserves to be enshrined in Cooperstown.

#3 Frank White – IF (34.8 WAR)

Coming in at #3 is another Kansas City Royals legend, who had an elite glove and also collected over 2,000 MLB hits. His name is Frank White and at one time he was a community college baseball player with no expectations of playing beyond college. That’s when the Royals created Royals Academy, a concept where strong and powerful athletes would be trained to become elite baseball players. Unfortunately, the Academy only produced three big-league players, but Frank White was one of them – the others being U.L. Washington and former Rangers manager Ron Washington. After White entered the Royals system, it was obvious he had big talent – his glove was incredible, he could fly on the basepaths and his offensive stats were respectable. He made his big league debut in 1973 and it took a few years for Royals fans to warm up to him but by 1976, he was a regular. He won his first of 8 Gold Gloves in 1977 and made his first of five All Star Games in ‘78. By the mid-80’s, White had developed some pop as well, crushing 22 home runs in back to back seasons. He was also clutch in the big moments, winning the 1980 ALCS MVP, crushing a home run in the ‘85 World Series and even hitting a deciding home run in the 1986 All Star Game. He was inducted into the Royals Hall of Fame in 1995 and is also heavily supported as a potential candidate for the Basebal Hall of Fame.

#2 Toby Harrah – IF (51.4 WAR)

One of the most underrated players of all time, Toby Harrah comes in at #2 on my list of the best undrafted free agents in MLB history. Although his name doesn’t pop off the page like that of some of the previous mentioned players, you might be surprised at how good this guy was. He was scouted as a High School prospect but went undrafted and entered into the workforce, getting a job at a factory. When Phillies scout Tony Lucadello found out that no one had drafted Harrah and that he was not playing college ball, he got in touch with him and signed him to play in the Phillies organization. He was later claimed by the Washington Senators, who promoted him in for a cup of coffee in 1969, then a full-time role in 1971. Harrah had not shown much power at this point, but he knew how to work a walk like nobody else, did not strike out much, had great speed, and would be a front office analytical dream come true this day in age. Even then, his value was clear and the Senators made him an everyday player. In 1972, the team moved to Arlington, becoming the Texas Rangers and Harrah made his first All Star Team. In 1974, he decided to try to hit for more power and crushed 21 bombs. In ‘75, he hit 20 more while hitting .293 with a .403 on-base-percentage and 23 stolen bases. Harrah had also vastly improved his defense – he was near-elite in almost every aspect of the game at this point. This type of production continued year after year, with perhaps his best season in 1977 when he hit 27 homers and led the league with 109 walks. Harrah was never a massive superstar, but he did everything right to help his team throughout a 17-year career. He retired as a 4-time All Star with a career 51.4 WAR, which is better than several Hall of Famers including Ralph Kiner, Jim Rice and Ted Simmons and the best of any one on this list. The JAWS ranking has him as the 28th greatest third baseman in MLB history. He was also the last player to bat for the Washington Senators, one half of the only duo to hit back to back inside the park homers, and once played every inning of a doubleheader at shortstop and never handled the ball once. He also hit one of three grand slams in a game for the Rangers, becoming the first team to ever do so. On top of being an amazing MLB talent, he is the answer to several trivia questions.

#1 Bruce Sutter – P (24.1 WAR)

Although it was tempting to put Harrah as my #1 overall pick, there was just no way I could put any one else other than the only undrafted free agent who was also a Hall of Famer as my #1 – and that would be of course Bruce Sutter, who finished his career with exactly 300 saves. Sutter was drafted after High School by the Senators in the 21st round, but did not sign and attended college at Old Dominion. From there, he was never drafted and ended up dropping out and playing in some semi-pro league. Chicago Cubs scout Ralph DiLullo noticed Sutter and signed him to play pro ball. This was just the first time Sutter’s career would be revived after being nearly dead in the water. He only pitched in a couple games in the minors when a pinched nerve required surgery. Then, in 1973 in A Ball, he had a 4.13 ERA, giving up 94 hits in 85 innings. The Cubs were considering releasing Sutter, but a minor league instructor named Fred Martin convinced them to let him teach Sutter a new pitch first. He taught Sutter the same pitch he taught Mike Krukow – the split-fingered baseball. It wasn’t a pitch that worked for every one, but Sutter’s hands were perfect for it and in 1974 , he used to dominate minor league batters to the tune of 1.38 ERA and 63 strikeouts in 64 innings. In 1976, he began the year in Triple-A but was quickly promoted and had a 2.7 ERA in his rookie MLB season. This was only the beginning. In 1977, he became the closer and had 31 saves with a 1.34 ERA, making the All Star team and garnering Cy Young votes. He became an MLB superstar, making the All Star team nearly every year. In 1979, he had a monster season, tying an NL record with 37 saves while taking home the Cy Young Award. He would later tie Dan Quisenberry’s MLB record of 45 saves in 1984. He led the league in saves 5 times, won 4 Rolaids Relief Awards, made 6 All Star teams and was eventually honored with induction into the National Baseball Hall of Fame, the first pitcher who never started a game to become a Hall of Famer.

10 ELITE MLB Players SNUBBED From HALL OF FAME - Including NEW SNUB CARLOS BELTRAN!! SNUBBED Part 3

Welcome to another edition of MLB Hall of Fame SNUBS and today, we’ll be ranking #30-#21 along with some updates to the previous 2 videos which will be linked at the end of this one so you can check out my TOP 20 SNUBS of all time. Before getting into the main list, there have been some fortunate updates to my Top 10 list.

In the recent 2023 Hall of Fame election, my #6 snub of all time was finally elected to the Hall of Fame and it’s the great Scott Rolen, who was an elite player on both sides of the ball. Rolen was a Rookie of the Year winner who ended his career with 8 Gold Glove Awards. Based on defense alone, he would be a Hall of Fame candidate, but when you take into account his amazing bat and the fact that he averaged 28 home runs a year for 8 straight seasons and drove in over 100 runs 5 times, it’s a shoe-in for me. Scott Rolen absolutely deserves enshrinement in Cooperstown and I’m very happy to remove him from my snubs list as he gets the plaque that he deserves.

The second update of course is the man who was my #1 snub of all time, the Crime Dog, Fred McGriff, who was elected by the Contemporary Era Committee after somehow being snubbed on the ballot for 15 years. In my opinion, the fact that this happened will be a black eye for the writer’s association for as long as they continue to be the sole voters on the traditional Hall of the Fame ballot. Fred McGriff, of course, came within 7 home runs of 500 and had he hit those measly 7 more homers, he would have probably been in a long time ago. McGriff was an elite hitter and excellent defender for over a decade averaging 30 home runs a year for an astonishing 16 years. Congratulations to both Fred McGriff and Scott Rolen for being elected into the Hall of Fame, better late than never.

New Snubs: Carlos Beltran, Ross Barnes

To replace McGriff and Rolen in the Top 10, I’m going to start with a brand new snub and that snub is Carlos Beltran, who made the Hall of Fame ballot this year and received only 46.5% of the vote. Beltran was similar to Scott Rolen in that he was a Rookie of the Year winner who was an elite defender and hitter, but Beltran had an even longer career, accumulating 435 home runs and 2,725 hits. He was a 9-time All Star, 3-time Gold Glover, 2-time Silver Slugger and drove in over 100 runs 8 times. It is certainly worth pointing out that Beltran lost many votes due to his involvement in the 2017 Houston Astros cheating scandal. He was a 40-year old player at the time in the last year of his career, so whatever cheating took place certainly didn’t change the fact that he had a Hall of Fame career. Will the voters seriously keep him out? He not only had a Hall of Fame career but also won the Roberto Clemente Award in 2013 for his humanitarian work off the field. He apologized for his involvement and took responsibility. Meanwhile, 2017 Astros manager A.J. Hinch and bench coach Alex Cora are continuing their managerial careers elsewhere without issue. Also, as a final point, sign-stealing has been part of the game forever and even though the Astros clearly took it too far, Beltran was far from the only one involved and to keep him out of the Hall of Fame for this one blemish on his otherwise stellar resume, in my opinion, is ridiculous. Carlos Beltran is my newest Top 10 Hall of Fame snub of all time, along with a player from the 19th century named Ross Barnes, who not only hit the first home run in MLB history but absolutely dominated the game during the early years of professional baseball.

For more info on Barnes, check out my video on him above. So, now that my Top 10 remains complete, let’s move on to 10 more snubs, #30 through 21. Keep in mind these snubs are understandably mostly borderline cases, but in my opinion all 10 should eventually be enshrined and I’ll explain why.. here we go...

#30 David Cone

Although most baseball fans remember David Cone as being an excellent pitcher, his name may not jump out as an obvious Hall of Famer. When digging a bit deeper though, I believe he has an excellent case. He had a 17-year that included five All-Star appearances, five World Series rings and even a Cy Young Award in 1992. Cone is 27th All-Time in career strikeouts with 2,668. His career WAR of 26.3 beats out many Hall of Fame starters including Don Drysdale and Whitey Ford. When examining his placement on the JAWS ranking, which evaluates Hall of Fame worthiness, Cone finds himself dropped in the middle of a massive list of Hall of Famers. Notice how Cone is mixed in with names like Juan Marichal and Bob Feller among others. He only had 194 career wins, but when considering everything else, does that warrant him falling off the ballot during his first year of eligibility? Cone also finished in the Top 6 for the Cy Young 5 times and his best year was a year he didn’t even win it, 1988, when he went 20-3 with a 2.22 ERA. Without the Cy Young, he is definitely a boderline case, but when you add that into the mix, it puts it over the top for me – David Cone should have a plaque.

#29 Jack Glasscock

He was the best shorstop of an entire century – ableit the 19th century. Called “The King of Shortstops,” deadball superstar Jack Glasscock had a 17-year career in which he collected over 2,000 hits. At that time, 2,000 career hits was no small feat as he was only the 6th player of all time to do it. However, his strongest asset was his defense. Glasscock led the National League in fielding percentage seven times and assists 6 times. When he retired in 1895, he had the Major League record for games played, putouts, assists, double plays and fielding percentage. Had the Hall of Fame existed at the time, he was have been a first ballot no brainer Hall of Famer. Unfortunately, by the time the Hall of Fame did exist, he was overshadowed by the greats of the 20th century and only received 2.6% of the vote in his one and only year on the ballot in 1936. Since then, he has only been forgotten even more, due largely to the fact that most of the teams he played for no longer exist – such as the Indianapolis Hoosiers and Louisville Colonels. He did, however, play two years for the New York Giants, including the outstanding 1890 season in which he led the league in hits and won the batting title with a .336 average. Despite the fact that his overall numbers may not be Hall of Fame worth by today’s standards, because he stood out above his peers as one of the best in the game for well over a decade, even if it was in the 19th century, Jack Glasscock deserves to be in the Hall of Fame.

#28 Luis Tiant

Coming up next is Luis Tiant, a pitcher who was on the ballot for 15 years and was never elected. He was also snubbed on 3 ballots for the Veteran’s Committee. Today he is 82 years old and still with us, so I’m hopeful he will be able to enjoy the moment when he is elected. And why should he be elected? How about a 19 year career in which he won at least 20 games 4 times, finished in the Top 6 for the Cy Young 3 times and had 2 ERA titles. He had 2,416 strikeouts, more than Sandy Koufax, Juan Marichal and Jim Palmer. In the postseason, Tiant went 3-0 with 2.86 ERA in 4 starts. He had all these accomplishments despite playing a large portion of his career at hitter friendly Fenway Park. He also pitched for the offensively light Cleveland Indians for the first 6 years of his career, and the lack of run support killed his record. For example, he went 12-11 in 1966 despite a 2.79 ERA. Five of his 12 wins that year were via the shutout. In 1968, he went 21-6 with an ERA of 1.6 Unfortunately, he only made 3 All Star Teams, but was certainly snubbed there. In 1973, for instance, he won 20 games – and had 12 at the All Star Break but did not make the All Star Team. All told, he won 229 games with a 3.3 ERA and an incredibly impressive 187 complete games. He is also one of two pitchers with two streaks of 40+ scoreless innings. The other is the great Walter Johnson.

#27 Tommy John

How could a player who had a Hall of Fame career who also has one of the most famous names in baseball history be left on the outside looking in? Even if we ignore the massive impact Tommy John had on the game by becoming the first player to make a successful comeback to the game after successful ligament replacement surgery, his career itself warrants induction. John pitched for an incredibly impressive 26 years. Aside from his incredible longevity, he won 288 career games – 12 shy of 300 – and won at least 20 games in 3 separate seasons. Although he never won a Cy Young Award, he certainly could have as he finished in the Top 10 four times, which includes two times when he was the runner-up. The only reason I have Tommy John ranked this low on my overall list of snubs is because he was only great for about a 4-year window and for most of his career was just good or average. Still, I consider longevity an important factor and considering he pitched for 26 years, his 3.34 ERA is impressive. When you combine his career numbers with the fact that he made an extraordinary comeback through a groundbreaking surgery that bears his name and continues to help hundreds of pitchers continue their careers despite experiencing what used to be career-ending injuries, it’s a shame that Tommy John isn’t in the Hall of Fame. Perhaps it shouldn’t be a surprise – the player with the most hits is not in, the player with the most home runs is not in and the player with the most famous name of all – also not in.

#26 Orel Hershiser

Up next is a player whose shelves are filled with so many awards, if you visited his home, you would just assume he’s a Hall of Famer. His name is Orel Hershiser and just to run through those awards before getting into his stats, he has a Cy Young Award, Major League Player of the Year Award, Silver Slugger, ALCS MVP, NLCS MVP, World Series MVP, and a Gold Glove Award. Add all that to a World Series Ring and 3 All Star Appearances. He was one of if not the best pitcher in the game during the late 80’s. At one point in 1988, he threw a record 59 consecutive scoreless innings. Although his career slowed down after the 80’s, he continued to be a dominant postseason pitcher and pitched well for both the Indians and Mets as well, retiring with a 2.59 ERA in 22 postseason games. Although his best regular season years were certainly with the Dodgers, especially the insane 1988 Cy Young season in which he went 23-8 with a 2.26 ERA, he was still good from 1995 to 1997 with Cleveland, when he went 45-21. His accomplishments and awards alone merit induction despite only winning 204 career games, which is partially due to poor run support. He did have a relatively high ERA as well at 3.48, but it has been proven you can get in with an ERA in 3’s – Jack Morris was recently inducted and he had a 3.9 career ERA. Bottom line, when you do what Hershiser did at his best then go on to win over 200 games while continuing to pitch well when it counts, you deserve a plaque in my opinion.

#25 Albert Belle

Next up is a player known more his insane temper and toxic relationship with the media than his talent on the field. This unfortunately may have kept him out of Cooperstown. After all, it’s the baseball writers who vote. Albert Belle got only 7% of the vote on his first ballot. The next year, he dropped to around 3% and fell off the ballot. He only played for 12 years but was an absolute machine during most of it, driving in over 100 runs 9 consecutive times. That includes the strike-shortened 1994 when he smashed 36 home runs in just 101 games. Belle finished in the Top 3 for MVP 3 times and in the Top 10 5 times, although he never won the award. He easily could have and should have in 1995 when he crushed a league leading 50 homers with 126 RBIs. He had a slugging percentage of .690 and an OPS over 1.000 and led his team to an easy division title. He also hit .317 that year but lost the MVP to Mo Vaughn, who hit an even .300 with 39 home runs. Belle was better in nearly every category but Vaughn took home the MVP. Belle did win the Player of the Year Award. In his career, he was a 5-time All Star and 5-time Silver Slugger as well and is the only player to ever hit 50 homers and 50 doubles in the same season. Unfortunately, he had to retire early due to a degenerative back condition, but he still managed 381 home runs, over 1200 RBIs and a .295 batting average. His career OPS of .933 is just 7 points below one Willie Mays and is better than Hank Aaron, Albert Pujols and Ken Griffey Jr. among many other greats of the game. To me, the only possible excuse to keep him out is his lack of longevity, but when you’re as good as he was, 12 years in more than enough.

#24 Carlos Delgado

Next up on the Hall of Fame snubs list is the great Carlos Delgado, who is slightly higher than Belle because he had a longer career at 17 years, allowing him to hit 473 homers – just 27 shy of 500. Aside from that, he also had a season where he could have easily taken home the MVP. It was 2003 and Delgado hit 42 homers with an incredible 145 RBIs while hitting .302 with an OPS over 1.000. Unfortunately, A-Rod, perhaps with a little assistance, outdid him in Texas and won the MVP. Since voters don’t consider juicers legit and won’t put them in the hall, I assume they must also credit Delgado then for being the true MVP that year. Aside from 2003, he was incredibly consistent, crushing at least 30 home runs 11 times, going over 40 3 times. Here’s one stat that might convince you Delgado is a Hall of Famer or at least deserved more than getting kicked off the ballot after one year. He drove in more runs than Mickey Mantle. When you combine that fact with the fact that he had nearly 500 homers, that’s all I need to know. Names on the list of similar players on baseball reference includ Willie McCovey, Jeff Bagwell and Willie Stargell. The voters did Delgado dirty when they failed to even give him 5% of the vote.

#23 Thurman Munson

Up next is a player whose career and life was cut short by a tragic plane crash. Had this never occurred, Munson would have likely waltzed into the Hall of Fame. Still, even with his shortened career, I think Munson deserves enshrinement. During his 11 year career, he made 7 All Star teams, won 3 Gold Gloves, and took home the Rookie of the Year Award as well as an MVP Award. That alone sounds close to a Hall of Famer. If it’s not enough, how about an absolutely phenomenal postseason career in which he hit .357 in 30 games, helping the Yankees win two World Series rings. He had 16 World Series starts and was unstoppable, hitting .373. Defensively, he was also dominant, throwing out 4 of 6 would-be base stealers during the ‘77 World Series. The only excuse to keep him out is his shortened career, in which he still hit .292 but only had 1,558 hits. Still, he did get the 10 year minimum in, has an MVP and was an absolute superstar during his time. When you add that to the postseason contributions, I believe he absolutely deserves a plaque and I’m shocked he was never voted in when you consider his tragic death as, for better or worse, I would assume he would have gotten some sympathy votes. Nevertheless, in my opinion, he’s a Hall of Famer with or without sympathy votes.

#22 Jim McCormick

It’s time to go way back in time again and talk about one of the early players of the game. Jim McCormick is another forgotten 19th century player who played pro ball from 1878 to 1887, just 10 years. However, during that time, his numbers were off the charts – even for early baseball stats. For example, he won 265 games in his career – nearly 300 – in just 10 years. In 1880, he led the league with an insane 45 wins, a number impossible to achieve today. He is 11th All Time with 466 Complete Games and is one of just 4 pitchers in baseball history with 4,000 innings pitched with an ERA under 2.50. The other 3 are all in the Hall of Fame – Christy Matthewson, Walter Johnson and Eddie Plank. In fact, when looking at his incredible numbers, it’s quite baffling he’s not in the Hall of Fame. The reason may be because he hasn’t been on the ballot in many decades and back when he was, he was held out for not reaching 300 wins, which most of his peers who made the Hall of Fame did. However, nowadays, 300 wins is rare and far from a requirement to get in. Jim McCormick is some one whose case needs to be re-evaluated and he needs to be put in the Hall of Fame and hopefully he has descendants he can be there to celebrate the induction.

#21 Dwight Evans

Coming in as my ultimate snub in today’s edition of snubs is an amazing player who spent 20 years in the league, dominating in both the field and at the plate. His name is Dwight Evans. Evans may be the most baffling case of some one who didn’t even receive 5% of the vote, which caused him to fall off the ballot. This just goes to show many of these voters don’t do the slightest bit of research when casting their ballot. This is some one who played 20 years, won 8 gold gloves, accumulated over 2,400 hits and crushed 385 home runs. He was a three-time All Star and 2-time Silver Slugger as well. The offensive numbers alone make him a borderline case, but when you add in the 8 Gold Gloves, the case should become clear – Dwight Evans belongs in. His career WAR of 67.2 is higher than Willie McCovey, Duke Snider and Jackie Robinson. Along with his power, Evans had a knack for getting on base and led the league in walks 3 times. He simply helped his teams win games for 20 years on both sides of the ball and even though he didn’t reach any of the main milestone numbers, Evans was great for a sustained period of time and deserves a plaque in Cooperstown.

Top 20 MLB ACTIVE Draft Steals

Welcome to another Humm Baby Baseball countdown and today we’ll wrap up my series on MLB Draft Steals by going down the list of my Top 25 MLB Active Draft Steals. This includes only players that are currently active and on a Major League roster and each of these players signed out of a draft in which they were taken in no higher than the 5th round. Players of the past like Mike Piazza, Ozzie Smith and John Smoltz have proven that you don’t have to take a prospect in the first or second round in order to find a future Hall of Famer. That hasn’t changed and today we’ll talk about 20 MLB stars who were all taken very late in the draft. I am ranking these based not just on how good the player is, but also on how late they were taken. The later the pick, the better the steal. A few honorable mentions include..

Honorable Mentions

• Mike Yastrzemski - 14th Round

• Jared Walsh - 39th Round

• Adam Frazier - 6th Round

• Cedric Mullins - 13th Round

• Tommy La Stella - 8th Round

• Matt Moore - 8th Round

• Matt Carpenter - 13th Round

20. Corey Dickerson - 8th Round

First up is Corey Dickerson, who was a massive superstar at Meridian Community College in Mississippi. He hit .459 with 21 bombs during his freshman year. Still, he wasn’t taken until the 8th round by the Rockies in 2010, who had also drafted him in the 29th round out of High School in 2009. Dickerson destroyed Rookie Ball with a .348 average and 13 bombs. He moved quickly through the Minors and found his way into the Rockies lineup by mid-2013. In 2014, he crushed 24 bombs with a .312 batting average and .931 OPS. He was later traded to the Rays where he hit 27 homers in 2017, making the All Star Team. In 2018, he hit .300 for the Pirates and won a Gold Glove. Dickerson recently signed with the Nationals for the 2023 season.

19. Nestor Cortes Jr - 36th Round

Coming in at #17 is a player with a chance to move much higher a list like this in the future, Nestor Cortes Jr. He was not taken until the 36th round in 2013, but absolutely dominated the minor leagues with an 11-4 record and 1.53 ERA in 2016. He continued to pitch well in the minors until, surprisingly, the Yankees left him unprotected and he was taken in the Rule 5 Draft by the Orioles. Luckily for the Yankees, the O’s were not patient with him and after a couple bad outings, they sent him back to New York. He went 5-1 in 2019, then after a stint with the Mariners, came back to the Yankees where he finally had his breakout season in 2022 going 12-4 with a 2.44 ERA and 163 strikeouts, making his first All Star Team. He is currently slated to be in the rotation for the 2023 and could end up being an amazing steal from the 36th round.

18. Ty France - 34th Round

Next up is another player who could be ranked much higher on a list like this in a few years. Ty France was taken all the way down in the 34th round of the 2015 Draft and as of now, is the only player from that round to make the big leagues. France played at San Diego State University and showed some ability by hitting .337 across four seasons. Nevertheless, he wasn’t considered a big prospect and not taken until the 1,017th pick by the Padres. He hit so well in the Minors, the Padres had no choice but to keep moving him up until 2019, when he made Triple A look like T-Ball, hitting .399 with an OPS over 1.200. He hit 27 home runs in just 76 games, forcing the Padres to bring him up to the big leagues. He never got a full opportunity, however, until he joined the Mariners lineup in 2021 and hit .291 with 18 homers. France could go on to become one of the greatest steals of all time, but he is still at the beginning of his big league career.

17. Jordan Romano - 10th Round

Undrafted out of High School, Jordan Romano at first attended Connors State College in Muskogee, Oklahoma, where he 0-1 with an 8.68 ERA, not exactly stellar numbers. The next year, he improved drastically and transferred to Oral Roberts, where he became the closer, saving 11 games with a 2.66 ERA. The Blue Jays took him in the 10th round of the 2014 Draft, paying him a $25,000 signing bonus. The Jays almost lost him when the White Sox took him in the Rule 5 Draft in 2018, but after a trade to the Rangers, he was returned to Toronto. Despite a high ERA in the Triple A, his strikeout stuff was good enough to give him an opportunity and in 2020, Romano broke through with a 1.23 ERA in 15 apperanaces. In ‘21, he became the closer and last season, he made his first All Star Team and saved 36 games with a 2.11 ERA.

16. Blake Treinen - 7th Round

Next up is a player with an amazing story. Blake Treinen retired from baseball for the first time after his freshmen year of High School. He had some weight issues and struggled with borderline Type 2 Diabetes. Treinen worked hard to get in shape and by his Junior year realized he had grown 6 inches and could throw a ball harder than ever. He gave baseball another try and pitched well, but had no scholarship offers. He went to a Junior College called Baker, where he struggled to get playing time. After a transfer to Arkansas, he was told that they don’t hold open tryouts and denied even the opportunity to play ball. Finally, Treinen was given a chance at South Dakota State, where he went 7-3 with a 3.00 ERA. The A’s took him in the 7th round and later traded him to the Nationals. In 2014, Treinen, against all odds, made it to the big leagues and pitched well, with a 2.49 ERA in 15 games. The A’s eventually got their man back in another trade and in 2018, Treinen was one of the best in the game, allowing just 46 hits in 80 innings with a stunning 0.78 ERA. He’s been one of the most effective relievers out of the Dodgers bullpen since 2020 and an absolutely incredible steal from the 7th Round.

15. Max Muncy -5th Round

Max Muncy had a nice career at Baylor where he hit .311 with 27 homers. It wasn’t enough to get him very high in the draft however, as he wasn’t taken until the 5th round when the Oakland A’s took him as the 169th overall pick. He hit 25 homers with 100 RBIs during his first full minor league season and became a prospect to keep an eye on for Oakland. Unfortunately, he didn’t hit well with the big league club during two stints in 2015 and 2016, looking like the dreaded Quadruple-A Player. The A’s released him during the end of Spring Training in 2017. He signed a Minor League deal with the Dodgers, earned another shot in the big leagues by 2018 and from there, became one of the premiere power hitters in the game, crushing 35 home runs in ‘18 and 35 again in ‘19. He has made two All Star Teams and already has 144 big league home runs.

14. Brandon Belt - 5th Round

Coming in at #14 is the Captain, Brandon Belt, who was taken in the 5th round of the 2009 Draft out of Texas. He was quickly a mid-season All Star with the High A San Jose Giants. He blasted through the minors all the way to Triple A in his first season, ending the year with a .352 average and 23 home runs across all levels. He was quickly considered a top prospect for the Giants and made his MLB debut in 2011. By 2012 he was a regular and helped the Giants win their second World Series in 3 years. Of course, he was also part of the 2014 World Championship team as well and hit one of the most dramatic homers in Giants history in the NLDS in Washington D.C. with this tie-breaking bomb in the 18th inning. He ended up spending 12 years with the Giants, getting on base consistently while playing phenomenal defense at first base. In 2021, he crushed 29 home runs and helped the Giants win a franchise record 107 games. For the 2023 season, he has signed with the Blue Jays.

13. Chris Bassitt - 16th Round

Up next on the list is a pitcher named Chris Bassitt, who had a 1.62 ERA as a reliever during his Junior year at the University of Akron. He wasn’t taken until the 16th round by the Chicago White Sox. His excellence continued in the Minor Leagues and the organization converted him to a starter. Bassitt made his big league debut in 2014. After that season, the Sox sent him to the A’s along with Marcus Semien, who we may be discussing soon as well. Bassitt went on to be an All Star in Oakland. In 2020, he had a 2.59 ERA. In 2022, Bassitt went 15-9 for the Mets, helping them win over 100 games. After the season, he signed a 3-year, $63 million contract with the Blue Jays. Not bad for a 16th Round Pick.

12. Jake Cronenworth - 7th Round

Just cracking the Top 10 is Jake Cronenworth, who is still very early in his career. He played for the Michigan Wolverines, hitting .338 in his final year with 6 homers. The Tampa Bay Rays took him but not until the 7th round. He hit extremely well for five years in the Rays organization, but before he could make his big league debut, he was traded to the Padres. The Padres thanked the Rays for developing him for them, put him right in their lineup and let him rake as he hit .285 his rookie year, finishing second in the Rookie of the Year voting. The next season, in 2021, he made his first All Star Team and found his power stroke, crushing 21 homers. He made the All Star Team again in 2022 and drove in a career high 88 runs. He also hit well in the postseason for San Diego and is already a definite great steal as a 7th round pick even though the Rays never took advantage.

11. Brandon Woodruff - 11th Round

Coming up next is pitcher Brandon Woodruff, who was a solid prospect out of High School and was as originally taken in the 5th round by the Rangers but did not sign. His stock fell a bit after struggling at Mississippi State with a 6.75 ERA his Junior Year. The Brewers took him in the 11th round. In 2016, he went 14-9 with a 2.68 between Single and Double-A, becoming a serious pitching prospect for Milwaukee. The next year, he made his big league debut. By 2019, he worked his way to the top of the Brewers rotation, making the All Star Team and going 11-3 with a 3.62 ERA. He made another All Star Team in 2021 and then, in 2022, went 13-4 with a 3.02 ERA. He, along with Corbin Burnes, has become one of the most solid 1-2 punches at the top of a rotation in the game. Burns, by the way, was also a nice steal from the 4th round, but this list is only considering those taken in the 5th and lower.

10. Kyle Hendricks - 8th Round

Next up, we have The Professor, Kyle Hendricks, who was a solid pitcher for the Dartmouth Big Green. He was not considered a huge prospect and not taken until the 8th round by the Texas Rangers. Shortly after his pro career began, the Rangers traded him to the Cubs as part of a trade that sent Ryan Dempster to the Rangers. He quickly turned heads in the Cubs organization, going 13-4 with an even 2 ERA between Double and Triple A. He was promoted to the big leagues the next season and had a stellar rookie year, going 7-2 with a 2.46 ERA. In 2016, he was one of the best in the league, going 16-8 with a 2.13 ERA, then continued to dominate during the postseason, helping the Cubs win their first World Series since Teddy Roosevelt was president. Although he hasn’t repeated his 2016 season, Hendricks has continued to be a staple in the Cubs rotation and is still on their roster for the 2023 season.

9. Joc Pederson - 11th Round

Coming in at #9 is a fantastic steal in the 11st round, taken out of Palo Alto High School, Joc Pederson. He hit extremely well in the minors and after the 2013 season in which he hit 22 home runs, Joc was ranked as the #1 Dodgers Prospect by Baseball America. He became a full time big leaguer in 2015 and made the All Star Team, finishing the season with 26 bombs. His best season came in 2019 when he crushed 36 home runs. He came through for the Dodgers in 2020 and then the Braves in 2021 with some key postseason home runs, helping each team win a World Series. He smashed over 20 home runs again in 2022 for the Giants and now has a 171 career homers as an 11th Round Pick.

8. Marcus Semien - 6th Round

Next up is a huge star in the game named Marcus Semien, who played college ball at Cal. He was a solid prospect, but after hitting .275 his Junior year, his stock dropped a bit and he fell all the way to the 6th round. It was the White Sox who took him and he moved quickly through the minors, earning a promotion in just his third season. In 2014, he got an extended shot in Chicago but hit just .234 with 6 homers in 64 games. It was after this season when the White Sox packaged him up with Chris Bassitt and a couple others to send to Oakland for Jeff Samardzija and Michael Ynoa. The Sox got some value from these players but they certainly lost the trade. Semien became an everyday player in Oakland and crushed 27 homers in 2016. He was an MVP candidate in 2019 when he hit .285 with 33 homers. He has only missed about 8 games in the past 4 years. Before the 2022 season, he signed a 7-year deal worth $175 million with the Rangers.

7. Jeff McNeil - 12th Round

Next up is Squirrel, Jeff McNeil, who didn’t even play baseball during his Senior year at high school because he was focused on golf. He eventually returned to baseball at CSU Long Beach and hit .348 his Junior Year. The Mets took notice and drafted McNeil but not until the 12th round. His hitting ability and incredible speed were immediately noticeable in the minors as he hit .292 in A Ball with 17 steals. The next year, 2015, he hit .308 and was slowly climbing the Mets Top Prospects List. Still, he wasn’t promoted until 2018 as he was tearing up Triple-A with Las Vegas. With New York, he hit .329, finishing 6th for the Rook of the Year. The next year, his bat exploded with 23 bombs and a .318 average. He also made the All Star Team. He led the league with a .326 batting average last year and recently signed a lucrative extension with the Mets. He was an absolutely fantastic steal for the Mets in the 12th Round.

6. Robbie Ray -12th Round

Ray was an elite High School pitcher in the Nasvhille area who went 7-1 with 0.95 ERA during his Senior Year. He was planning to play at Arkansas when the Washington Nationals drafted him 12th round and offered a signing bonus of nearly $800,000, an amount usually allocated for fourth round picks. It was an offer he couldn’t refuse and Ray entered the Minor Leagues. Unlike many players on this list, the minors weren’t always easy for Ray and he struggled in High A, going 4-12 with a 6.56 ERA. The Nationals stuck with him, though, and by 2013 he had completely turned his career around, drastically improving his strikeout stuff and going 11-5 with a 3.36 ERA. With his improved value, the Nats traded him to Detroit, and Ray made his big leauge debut in 2014. He was later traded to the Diamondbacks and after two rough seasons, everything came together in 2017 when he went 15-5 and made the All Star Team. With the Blue Jays in 2021, Ray was one of the best in the game, striking out a league leading 248 batters and taking home the Cy Young Award. In November of 2021, he signed a 5 year, $115 million contract with the Seattle Mariners.

5. Mookie Betts - 5th Round

Although the next player wasn’t taken too insultingly low, I still have to put him very high on the list because Mookie Betts went from a 5th round pick to an American League MVP. He was a fantastic High School athlete and hit .548 with 24 steals his Junior Year. However, he committed to attend Tennessee on a scholarship, which certainly hurt his draft stock. He was taken in the 5th round but offered a $750,000 bonus. He signed with the Red Sox and went on to dominate the minors, hitting .346 in 2014 between Double and Triple A, earning a call up to the big leagues. From there, the rest is history as Betts became one of the greatest players in the game, making the All Star Team every year, winning Gold Glove after Gold Glove and even taking home the MVP in 2018. He helped the Red Sox win a World Series then did the same for the Dodgers in 2020. In his first 9 years, he already has 213 home runs, 6 Gold Gloves, an MVP and a batting title.

4. Josh Hader -19th Round

Moving into the top 3, we have Josh Hader, who makes it this high because he was taken all the way down in the 19th round. Hader went 10-0 with 0.3 ERA in High School, but at that time had a fastball in the mid-80’s. The Orioles took him as the 582nd overall pick and he is just one of the three players from his round to make the big leagues. Hader adjusted his workout routine and increased his velocity dramatically in the Minors. He had a 2.77 ERA in 2013 and made the Single A All Star Team. After the season, he was traded to Houston and continued to pitch well in their system as a starter. In 2016, he was traded to the Brewers and continued to start games in the Minors. However, after he was promoted in 2017, he pitched so well out of the bullpen that Hader became a reliever and won the Reliever of the Year award in 2018 despite not yet being a full time closer. He took over the closer role for good in 2019 and became one of the most dominant in the game. In 2021, he reached 400 strikeouts faster than any pitcher in history innings-wise. He’s already made four All Star Teams and has 131 career saves. He was traded to the Padres in 2022 and after some early struggles, pitched well for them during the postseason.

3. Jacob Degrom - 9th Round

Incredibly, one of the greatest pitchers of his generation was not even selected out of High School and was exclusively a shortstop throughout his first two college seasons. I’m talking about Jacob Degrom, who wasn’t drafted until the 10th Round of the 2010 Draft by the New York Mets. Early in his Minor League career, he had to undergo Tommy John surgery, but came back strong in 2012, going 9-3 with a 2.43 ERA in A Ball. In 2013 The Mets added him to their 40-man Roster to protect him from the Rule 5 Draft. He made his Major League Debut in 2014 and in 22 starts had a 2.69 ERA with 144 strikeouts in 140 innings. DeGrom took home the Rookie of the Year award and went on to become one of MLB’s premiere starters, winning back to back Cy Young awards in 2018 and 2019. He’s made four All Star teams and recently signed a 5-year $185 million deal with the Texas Rangers.

2. J.D. Martinez - 20th Round

Just missing out on #1 is J.D. Martinez, who gets this high not only because he is a 5-time All Star with nearly 300 career home runs, but because he was taken shockingly in the 20th round. He played college baseball at Nova Southeastern University, where he set the school home run record with 32. He was an RBI machine who hit .394 and absolutely should have gone higher in the draft. However, because he went to a Division II school, he wasn’t considered too hot of a prospect and wasn’t taken until the 20th round when he was selected by the Houston Astros. He tore up the minor leagues, hitting well over .330 at each level, until the Astros promoted him in 2011. Unfortunately, he bounced back and forth between the minors and big leagues for the next 3 years until the Astros released him just as he was ready to hit his stride in 2014. He signed with the Tigers and hit .315 with 23 home runs. From there, he only got better, hitting 38 bombs the next season and becoming an All Star. He had his best years, however, in Boston and was instrumental in 2018, hitting 43 bombs with 130 RBIs, leading the team to a World Series ring. He recently signed a $10 million deal to play for the Dodgers in 2023.

1. Paul Goldschmidt - 8th Round

Coming in at #1 on my list of the Top 20 Active MLB Steals is an 8th Round selection named Paul Goldschmidt. He played college ball at Texas State and set Bobcat career records with 36 home runs and 179 RBIs. Still, he wasn’t taken until the 8th round of the ‘09 draft by the Arizona Diamondbacks. The Minor Leagues were child’s play for Goldschmidt who crushed 35 home runs in High A with a .314 average. The next year, he had 30 homers in Double-A when the D-Backs promoted him. From there, he became an MLB superstar, making 6 straight All Star teams and twice finishing runner-up for the MVP in Arizona. He hit 36 homers and drove in 125 runs in 2013 and helped the Diamondbacks make the postseason twice. He was later traded to St. Louis, where he won the 2022 MVP award after hitting .317 with 35 bombs. Goldschmidt is one of the best in the game and was a superb steal for the D-backs in the 8th round.

Top 10 MLB FLASH IN THE PANS Of ALL TIME.. Here Then Gone ONE-HIT Wonders!!

Welcome to another Top 10 Ranking and in today’s video, we’ll be looking at the Top 10 Flash in the Pans – players who were absolutely elite for a short amount of time but were unable to sustain that success for very long. To make this list, players had to have between 1-3 amazing seasons that created big hype and expectations. However, they ended up being here and gone flash in the pan players who could never replicate that success again.

10. Mark Prior

Mark Prior

The first player on the list is one of the most hyped up prospects of all time, Mark Prior. He was taken in the 1st round twice. My busts videos have received quite a bit of criticism for not including Mark Prior, but the reason I didn’t is simple – he did have one great year in the big leagues. After being taken second overall by the Cubs, Prior went 5-2 with a 2.29 ERA in the minors before being called up. He had a decent rookie year, going 6-6 with a 3.32 ERA but followed it up with the season the Cubs were hoping for. In 2003, Prior threw a shutout in his second start of the season and ended the year going 18-6, making the All Star Team and striking out 245 batters in 211 innings. He helped the Cubs make the playoffs then threw a complete game 2-hitter in the NLDS. He also pitched extremely well in the NLCS, winning Game 2 then throwing 7 scoreless innings in Game 6. Unfortunately, this was that historic moment when the Cubs completely collapsed. We all remember the Gonzalez error, the Bartman incident, Moises Alou freaking out over it and the complete meltdown that occurred, leading to the Marlins victory. However, Mark Prior still had a fantastic season and for that year alone, doesn’t belong in a Top 20 Busts list in my opinion. He fits better in this Flash in the Pan list as Prior only pitched three more seasons in the big leagues, struggling with injures and under performance the entire time. He continued to pitch in the minors and independent leagues for years, but continued to struggle to stay healthy. He retired in 2013 after a stint with the Reds Triple-A team, but for a short time in 2003, he did live up to the hype.

9. Chase Headley

Coming up next is a San Diego Padres second round pick who first got called up to the big leagues in 2007. By ‘09, he was a regular in the lineup, hitting around .265 per year with about 9-12 home runs. Suddenly, in 2012 at age 28, Headley had his breakout season that no one saw coming – not even Headley himself who set a goal of hitting 15 homers and 75 RBIs. Instead, he crushed 31 bombs and led the league with 115 runs driven in. He finished 5th in the MVP voting, won a Silver Slugger and won the NL Player of the Month award twice during the season. He also had a great year defensively and took home a Gold Glove. Headley set a career high in basically every offensive category and was suddenly on the verge of becoming a legit MLB superstar. That is, until 2013, when he was injured in Spring Training and after returning, reverted back to the normal Chase Headley, hitting just .250 with 13 home runs. In 2014, he was traded to the Yankees with whom he later signed a 3-year deal. He was a regular in the lineup for them but never got close to replicating his amazing 2012 season. He returned to the Padres in 2018 but was released after hitting just .115 in 52 at bats. Although Headley had a respectable 12 year career, he was a legitimate power hitting star for a quick flash in 2012.

8. Ubaldo Jimenez

Ubaldo Jimenez

One team that has always struggled to find elite starting pitching has been the Colorado Rockies. However, at one time, they had what appeared to be hands down the best pitcher in the game. The Rockies drafted Ubaldo Jimenez as an amateur free agent in 2001. He worked his way slowly through the minors, but eventually earned a call up in 2006 after going 14-4 between Triple and Double-A. He became a solid arm in the rotation but nothing overly spectacular. That is, until 2010, when Jimenez suddenly took his performance to another level, starting with the first no-hitter in Rockies history on April 17th. He won five games in the month of April alone and set a franchise record with 25 1/3rd consecutive scoreless innings then broke his own record later that season, throwing 33 straight. He won 11 of his first 12 starts, maintain an ERA under 1. By the All-Star Game, he was 15-1 with a 2.2 ERA. The Rockies appeared to have found the elite starter they were looking for. He finished the year 19-8 with a 2.88 ERA, struggling a bit down the stretch. This remarkable performance put his name on the map and is what likely allowed him to play another 7 seasons in the big leagues. He never came close to repeating it. He started 2011 going 6-9 with a 4.46 ERA and was traded to Cleveland. There, he went on to lead the league with 17 losses in 2012. He had a nice rebound in 2013, going 13-9 with a 3.3 ERA but 2010 was his only All Star season and Jimenez ended up retiring in 2020 after being released from his second stint with the Rockies.

7. Zoilo Versalles

Zoilo Versalles receiving the MVP Award

Versalles was a Cuban ballplayer signed as by the Washington Senators in 1958. He played well in the minors but struggled in the bigs after his first callup in 1959, hitting just .153 with a homer. In 1960, it was more of the same as he hit .133, causing the Senators to trade him to the Twins. He found his comfort zone there and ended up a regular in the lineup, hitting .241 with 17 homers in 1962. In 1963, he led the league in triples and bumped his average up to .261. However, everything came together in 1965 when Versalles suddenly became a hitting machine, finding the gaps, driving the ball down the lines and hitting for power with 19 home runs. He ended up leading the league in doubles, triples, runs and total bases and was second in hits. He made the All-Star Team, had a 7.2 WAR for the season and won a Gold Glove. Unsurprisingly, he won the American League MVP Award. At just 26 years old, it looked like Versalles might be on a Hall of Fame path. Unfortunately, his performance declined after that season as he hit just .249 in 1966 then .200 in ‘67 with just 6 home runs despite 581 at bats. He never led the league in an offensive category again after the amazing 1965 season. He bounced around a bit but never played in the big leagues again after hitting .191 with for the 1971 Braves. Sadly, he struggled financially after retirement and ended up having to sell his MVP Award. Although Versalles certainly didn’t have a Hall-of-Fame career, he should still be remembered for an amazing run in the mid-60’s when he was, ever so briefly, one of the best players in the game.

6. Dontrelle Willis

Next up is the D-Train, Dontrelle Willis, who was taken in the 8th round by the Chicago Cubs in the year 2000. He was traded to the Marlins in 2002 and went 12-2 with a 1.83 ERA in the minor leagues. In 2003, he was a regular in the Marlins rotation and had a phenomenal rookie year, going 14-6 with a 3.3 ERA, taking home the Rookie of the Year. Willis had a memorable old-time baseball windup that included a high leg kick and massive twist of the body. By 2005, Willis was one of the best in the game and started the year 5-0 with a 1.29 ERA. He made the All Star Team and finished the year with a 22-10 record, leading the league with 7 complete games and 5 shutouts. He finished 2nd in the Cy Young voting to Chris Carpenter but did win the Warren Spahn Award, given to the best left-handed pitcher in each league. The hype around Willis was massive as a Rookie of the Year winner who had just won 22 games as a 23-year old. Unfortunately, this was the height of his success. He started 2006 by going 1-6 with a 4.93 ERA and ended the year with a 12-12 record. In 2007, he went 10-15 with a terrible 5.17 ERA, leading the National League in runs allowed. He spent the rest of his career trying to stay off the disabled list, bouncing around from team to team but never winning more than 2 games in an entire season. His last year was 2011, when he went 1-6 for the Reds. Willis continued to attempt comebacks through 2015, when he finally announced his retirement from the game.

5. Kevin Maas

Kevin Maas

Next up is Kevin Maas. Maas was a big time prospect for the Yankees who appeared to be the real deal once he made it to the majors. Maas was taken in the 22nd round but showed immense talent in the minor leagues by hitting 28 home runs in 1988 with a .271 batting average and .382 on-base percentage. He became one of the Yankees top prospects and was promoted midway through the 1990 season. The Yankees hoped that they had found their next great Yankee slugger, who could eventually be the heir to Don Mattingly. He came out of the gate on fire, starting his career about as hot as possible, crushing 10 home runs in his first 72 at bats, an MLB record at the time. In one 3-game series in Texas, Maas homered off Kevin Brown, Bobby Witt and Nolan Ryan. Despite not being called up until July and only playing in 79 games, he still managed to crush 21 home runs and finished 2nd in the Rookie of the Year only because he played half a season. Maas was a dead pull hitter and pitchers, catchers and coaches certainly studied him going into the 1991 season. He had a huge sophomore slump, hitting just .220. He managed to hit 23 home runs but it took almost twice as many at bats as he had when he hit 21 the prior season. By 1993, he turned into a fringe prospect, bouncing back and forth between Triple A until moving on to other organizations in 1994, who kept him in the minors. Maas hit .193 including his final big league homer for the Twins in 1995 and was out of baseball two years later. During his brief rookie year, Maas put on an insane display of power that has rarely been seen. He was one of the greatest flash in the pans of all time.

4. Eric Gagne

Next up is a pitcher who had an interesting path the big leagues, not signing when drafted by the White Sox in the 30th round of the ‘94 draft to attend Seminole State College in Oklahoma. He wasn’t drafted in 1995 at all but signed as a free agent with the Dodgers. He was a starter in the minor leagues and showed excellent stuff, going 12-4 with about a 10 per 9 strikeout ratio in 1999. Through his first 5 big league starts, Gagne had a 2.1 ERA. However, the Dodgers needed a closer entering the 2002 season and thought Gagne might work in the role. It turned out they were right as he dominated batters, striking out 114 in 82 innings of work while saving 52 games for LA. He made his first All Star Team and immediately became known as one of the elite closers of the game. Then, in 2003, he was even better, closing out a league leading 55 games with a sick 1.2 ERA. He averaged 15 strikeouts per 9 innings and easily won the Cy Young Award despite being a reliever. He had his third and final successful season in 2004, saving 45 games with a 2.19 ERA. Unfortunately, injuries limited his 2005 season he had to have Tommy John Surgery. He experienced several setbacks and other injuries as he attempted to come back. He became a free agent by 2007 and signed with the Rangers, but continued to struggle with injuries although he managed 16 saves. He pitched for the Red Sox and Brewers later on but with limited to no success. He attempted a comeback with the Dodgers in 2010 but was released during Spring Training. It is unfortunate that Gagne wasn’t able to have a healthy and long MLB career but for three years, there was nobody more feared coming out of a bullpen than Eric Gagne.

3. Mark Fidyrch

Mark Fidrych

Although his success was short-lived, Mark “The Bird” Fidyrch is one of the memorable players of all time. This 6’3” pitcher was drafted by the Tigers and brought a fun quirkiness to the mound as well as, for a while, pure domination. After spending his first two years in the minors, Fidyrch was a non-roster invitee during 1976 Spring Training. He impressed enough to make the Opening Day roster, then, after throwing a 2-hit complete game in his first start, earned a spot in the rotation. The fans loved watching him, as he would march around the mound after each out, talk to the baseball and not allow the groundskeepers to work on the mound during the game. He completed nearly every game he started as the All Star Game approached and was elected not only to play in the game, but start it. Fidrych continued to show amazing stamina and stuff as he finished out the year with 19-9 record, 2.34 ERA and an incredible 24 complete games, including 4 shutouts. He won the Rookie of the Year award and finished 2nd in the Cy Young voting to Jim Palmer. The next season, Fidrich started to experience injury issues, starting just 11 games. He went 6-4 with a 2.89 ERA and was elected to the All Star Game although he couldn’t play due to injury. He was able to appear in just 7 games over the following two seasons, suffering from a torn rotator cuff that was never diagnosed or treated properly during his career. He made his last MLB appearances in 1980, going 2-3 with a 5.68 ERA. It is sad that Fidyrch’s injury was never diagnosed as he was a control pitcher who didn’t rely on heat and could have had a long and successful, perhaps a Hall of Fame, career, had he gotten the proper treatment. Still, he will always be remembered for his hilarious antics and amazing personality, along with his phenomenal rookie season.

2. Tim Lincecum

Tim Lincecum with Fresno Grizzlies mascot, Parker

Coming in at #2 is Tim Lincecum, who the Giants drafted 10th overall in the 2006 MLB Draft. It was seen as a slight risk given Lincecum’s smaller frame, but he absolutely dominated the minor leagues and the hype was through the roof in 2007 as he went 4-0 with a 0.29 ERA through 5 starts with the Fresno Grizzlies. He struck out 46 batters in 36 innings. The Giants were forced to promote him that year and he showed signs of brilliance, but it wasn’t until 2008 when The Freak hit his full potential. The domination was next level and Tim Lincecum became an instant superstar, striking out 265 batters and going 18-5 with a 2.62 ERA. He took home the Cy Young Award and was elected to the All Star Game. The following season, he did again – All Star Game and Cy Young Award - going 15-7 with a 2.48 ERA and 261 strikeouts. A star was born. He declined a bit in 2010, but was still solid, helping the Giants win their first World Series in San Francisco. He also pitched well in 2011 but his strikeout ratio fell to the lowest of his career and poor run support helped cause an unimpressive 13-14 record. By 2012, he was simply bad, going 3-10 with a 6.42 ERA during the first half. The 2-time Cy Young Award was demoted to the bullpen for the 2012 playoffs. He continued to pitch with the Giants through 2015, but never found the magic from his Cy Young Award seasons and eventually had hip surgery and signed with the Angels. He went 2-6 with a 9.16 ERA. After missing the entire 2017 season, Lincecum made one last comeback effort with the Rangers in 2019, but pitched poorly in Triple-A and never made it back to the big leagues. It should be noted that Lincecum did throw two no-hitters outside of his Cy Young seasons and was very effective in the postseason for the Giants. Still, Lincecum was easily the most unhittable and dominant pitcher in the game for a 2-year period until a slow decline led to the unfortunate end of his career.

1. Denny McLain

Denny McLain

Another extremely interesting character who pitched for the Tigers is Denny McLain. He began his pro career with the White Sox organization in 1962 and threw a no-hitter in his Minor League Debut. The Tigers were able to claim him on waivers by 1965, he was a regular in the rotation, going 16-6 with a 2.61 ERA. McLain was a great arm for the Tigers and continued to pitch well until suddenly, in 1968, he took it to another level entirely. During the first half of the year, he went 16-2 with a 2.09 ERA, putting himself on a pace to win over 30 games. He only got better from there, lowering his ERA to 1.96 for the year and finishing with an incredible 31-6 record, taking home not only the Cy Young Award but also the MVP Award. He had 280 strikeouts and just 63 walks, the best strikeout to walk ratio in Tigers history until Justin Verlander came along. McLain also completed an insane 28 games. The following season, he won 24 games and took home another Cy Young Award. He looked like a future Hall of Famer until suddenly the downfall began in 1970. Before the season even started, his off-the-field gambling issues became public and he apparently had connections to organized crime. McLain had always been an interesting character. For example, he was late to the 1969 All Star Game because he had a dental appointment. He barely pitched in 1970 due to three separate suspensions, one of them due to carrying a gun on the team flight. He was traded to the Washington Senators but led the league with 22 losses in 1971 and did not get along with his manager, Ted Williams. He pitched for the A’s in ‘72 and Brewers in ‘73 but had an ERA above 6 both seasons. Since retiring, McLain has been arrested multiple times and spent time in prison for trafficking cocaine, embezzlement, racketeering and mail fraud. During his sentencing in 1985, he said “I don’t know how you get to where I am from where I was 17 years ago,” McLain said. He was referring to the amazing 1968 season – still the last time in MLB history a pitcher won 30 games.

The Top 10 Most Inspirational MLB Comebacks of All Time

One of the greatest stories that occur in sports is the player comeback. It is so celebrated that MLB gives out the Comeback Player of The Year Award in both leagues every season. In 2021, the winner in the National League was Buster Posey, who won it for the second time in his career. The first time, in 2012, Posey came back from a horrific injury that ended his 2011 season to win the MVP award and lead the Giants to a World Series Championship in 2012. In the American League, the winner was Trey Mancini, who underwent an operation to remove a malignant tumor and 6 months of chemotherapy. Five months later, he was on the field again and won a World Series ring with the Astros in 2022. Amazing comebacks like these are somewhat rare, but do happen and today we’ll be counting down 10 more inspiring comeback stories. Before getting to the main list, however, I have two more honorable mentions in addition to Posey & Mancini.

Honorable Mention: WW2 Heroes

Former MLB pitcher Bob Feller serving at WW2

An extremely honorable mention goes to all the players who stopped their careers and went to serve their country in World War II, many of whom returned to the majors just as good if not better after three or more years of not playing the game. Some of the bigger names include Hank Greenberg, Yogi Berra, Warren Spahn, Bob Feller, Joe DiMaggio and Ted Williams. Ted Williams hit 521 home runs despite missing three entire seasons due to the war. Had the war not happened, he would have easily surpassed 600 homers and 3,000 hits. Many players were also seriously injured and still fought back to continue their careers. Cecil Travis suffered frostbite and nearly had his feet amputated and still returned to the Majors. Dixie Howell was held at a German POW Camp for 6 months. When he was finally freed by the Allied Forces, the 6’2” pitcher whose normal weight was 210 weighed 135 lbs. After missing five full seasons, he came back to go 8-3 with a 2.93 ERA for the White Sox.

Honorable Mention: Drew Robinson

Drew Robinson

In one of the most incredible stories in professional baseball history, we have former Texas Rangers prospect Drew Robinson. Robinson played 7 seasons in the minor leagues, hitting 20+ home runs in 2015 and 2016, then making the Rangers Opening Day Roster in 2017. He struggled and ended up bouncing back and forth between the big leagues and the minors, finishing the year with a .224 average and 6 homers. Robinson was eventually traded to the Cardinals, where he spent most of 2019 in the minors. So far, his MLB career had not gone the way he had hoped. On January 6th, 2020, he signed as a Free Agent with the Giants. Unfortunately, that was the year Spring Training suddenly ended due to Covid-19. Robinson returned to his home in Las Vegas, struggling with severe depression during a very depressing time. He decided to end his life, and attempted to do so with a handgun which he aimed at his temple and fired. Miraculously, he wasn’t killed and decided he wanted to live, calling 911 for help. He lost one eye, along with his sense of smell and taste. Robinson figured his baseball career was over, but after taking a round of batting practice, realized his ability to see the ball and time his swing wasn’t much different. The decision to swing must be made within a split second and muscle memory plays a huge role. As long as he could see the ball with one eye, Robinson believed he could still play. And the Giants gave him the opportunity. In an incredible comeback, Drew Robinson returned to professional baseball in 2021 and played in 38 Triple-A games for the Sacramento Rivercats. He hit three home runs, but unfortunately struggled to make consistent contact and never made it back to the big leagues, which is why he’s an honorable mention. Still, the fact that Robinson survived a suicide attempt using a gun to the head, lost an eye and still hit three more professional home runs is an incredible story of its own. Now, let’s get to the Top 10.

10. Tommy John

He has a name that no baseball fan hasn’t heard of. But long before Tommy John’s name was known for a surgery, he was a prospect with the Cleveland Indians. He had a great curveball and established himself as one of the premiere starters in the game after being traded to the White Sox. In 1968, he made the All Star Team and had an ERA of 1.98. Later, after being traded to the Dodgers, he went 16-7 in 1973 with a 3.1 ERA. In 1974, he was 13-3 with a 2.59 ERA. At this point, he had had a more than solid 12 year big league career, leading the league in shutouts twice and in win-loss percentage twice. Unfortunately, it was at this time when he had what was considered at the time to be a career-ending injury – a torn UCL. There was no coming back from that. That is, until orthopedic surgeon Frank Jobe, who worked for the Dodgers, performed a ligament replacement surgery on John. It was a revolutionary procedure that has since become standard surgery for pitchers, allowing them to continue their careers after injuries that were once career-ending. Tommy John indeed recovered while missing the 1975 season and returned in ‘76, going 10-10 with a 3.09 ERA. The next year, for the first time in his career, he won 20 games and finished 2nd in the Cy Young voting. The procedure was a massive success as Tommy John not only recovered but appeared to be even better. He made three straight All Star Teams and won 20 or more games in 3 out of 4 seasons. John played an incredible 14 more seasons after the surgery, giving him a 26 year career in which he won 288 games. He should certainly be in the Hall of Fame. The surgery has, of course, since been known as Tommy John Surgery, or simply “Tommy John.” Although his comeback has since become standard, since he was the first to do it and came back with such an insane degree of success, Tommy John is included in today’s list of the Top 10 comebacks of all time.

9. Jose Rijo

Most hardcore baseball fans from the late 80’s and early 90’s will remember Reds pitcher Jose Rijo, who was a constant in the Reds rotation for many years. In 1991, he went 15-6 with a 2.51 ERA, finishing fourth for the Cy Young Award. He won 111 games over 12 seasons, made an All Star team and led the Reds to a World Series ring in 1990, utterly dominating the A’s by going 2-0 with a 0.59 ERA. In 1995, he was limited to only 14 starts due to elbow injuries. Later that offseason, he had to have Tommy John surgery. Unfortunately, shoulder injuries in 1996 caused further issues and Rijo ended up needing 4 major surgeries. He was basically done with baseball and in October of 1998, became an unrestricted free agent who hadn’t played in 3 years. 1999 came and went and Rijo was unable to play. At this point, he was already considered a Reds legend who had a great 12-year career. He even appeared on the 2001 Hall of Fame Ballot, receiving one vote. Then, on July 1st, in the middle of the 2001 season, the Reds signed the 36-year old Rijo. Now coming out of the bullpen, Jose Rijo began his rehab assignment in Single A more than five years after his last professional pitch, as some one who had already appeared on the Hall of Fame Ballot. He worked his way through Double A then Triple A and finally got his call back up to the big leagues, where he had a 2.12 ERA in 13 appearances. He returned in 2002 as well, pitching out of the bullpen and starting 9 games before retiring. Rijo’s story may not be the most dramatic, but considering he was out of the game long enough to appear on the Hall of Fame ballot and still came back to give the Reds a strong bullpen arm is absolutely amazing and Jose Rijo makes #9 on this list.

8. Sean Burroughs, 3B

Coming in at #8 is third baseman Sean Burroughs, the son of Jeff Burroughs, who hit 240 big league home runs. Sean was supposed to be even better. As a child, he was a baseball prodigy, elite as both a pitcher and hitter. Burroughs threw back-to-back no-hitters in the Little League World Series and later led the USA to a gold medal in the 2000 Olympics. Burrough’s Minor League career started with a bang when he hit .363 in A Ball with 85 runs driven in. In 2001 in Triple A, he hit .322. Sports Illustrated touted him as a “can’t miss” prospect. And at first, they seemed to be right. Burroughs hit .286 in his first full season then .298 in 2004. He had a solid on-base percentage, didn’t strike out much, and looked like he was on a path to a successful big league career, Then, his career suddenly fell apart. A slide into second base at Dodger Stadium caused a broken blood capsule in his leg. He was traded to Tampa Bay, where he hit just .190 and spent most of 2006 in Triple A. He played in a few minor league games with the Mariners organization in 2007 and then was out of baseball. Burroughs ended up wandering the streets of Las Vegas, struggling with substance abuse. Burroughs said that when he was at his worse, he was eating cheeseburgers out of garbage cans. Fortunately, his story doesn’t end there. Nearly three years after his last professional game, Burroughs decided to try to get his life together and play baseball again. He says “I was out of shape with big, black bags under my eyes. Bad hair, hadn’t shaved for weeks on end. Hadn’t eaten anything other than french fries and Sluprees.” Burroughs moved back in with his parents, started working out, got back in baseball shape and called his agent to find any opportunity anywhere. His agent got in touch with the Diamondbacks and convinced them to sign him to a Minor League deal. He tore Triple A up that year, hitting .412, earning a callup to return to Major League Baseball. He hit .273 with the Diamondbacks, hitting his first MLB home run in 6 years. Burroughs retired after 2013 and never became the superstar he was expected to become, but had one of the most inspiring comebacks in MLB history.

7. Matt Bush

Matt Bush as a young prospect with the Padres organization

Up next is the #1 overall pick in the 2004 MLB Draft, Matt Bush. He was a shortstop and pitcher with an incredible arm and powerful bat. In High School, Bush hit .450 with 11 home runs while maintaining a 0.73 ERA on the mound. He was a 5-tool talent with an insane ceiling. However, troubles began before his professional career even got going. He was suspended for taking part in a fight outside of a bar in Arizona. He eventually hit just .192 with no home runs in his first Minor League season. The next season, his first full year, he hit just .221 with 2 homers in A Ball despite 453 at bats. Things weren’t looking on the field for the first overall pick. Off the field, things were even worse. He was arrested a second time for fighting in a bar, and received multiple DUIs. He showed up to games hung over and in 2007, hit .204 with a single home run. The Padres considered him a complete bust and traded him to the Blue Jays, who put him on a zero tolerance policy. That lasted about a month when Bush reportedly threw a baseball at a woman’s head, then banged on her car window after she drew markings on his face at a party. The next day, he was released and missed the entire 2009 season. Every comeback attempt from there was thwarted by another of his insane antics. In 2012, he was set to began the season in Triple A with the Rays organization, now as a pitcher, until he crashed his car three times in a matter of hours, first colliding with another car on an illegal U-turn, then hitting a light pole, then knocking a 72-year old man from his motorcycle, severely injuring him. He left each scene of each accident. He spent the entire 2012 season in jail and was charged with a long list of counts including one count of DUI with serious bodily injury and two counts of leaving the scene of an accident. He was released from prison in October 2015 and hadn’t played a game of professional baseball in over four years. He got a job at Golden Corral and, in an attempt to return to the game, held a showcase right there in the Golden Corral parking lot, since it was the only place was allowed to go. Incredibly, he impressed Rangers scouts enough that they brought him to Texas in December for a more formal tryout and to make a very long story short, Bush signed with the Rangers, went to the Minors and earned his first call up to the Major Leagues, 12 years after being taken first overall in the 2004 MLB Draft. Bush was kept on a no-tolerance policy with several requirements and stipulations and this time, he stuck to it. He went 7-2 with a 2.48 ERA in 2016 and began an MLB career that continues today with the Milwaukee Brewers. Although there’s no possible way to excuse Bush’s behavior early in his career, he did serve his time and completely change his life, while making one of the most improbable comebacks of all time.

6. Rick Ankiel

Rick Ankiel with the Astros

Coming in at #6 is a former pitcher named Rick Ankiel. In High School, Ankiel was a stud, going 11-1 with a .47 ERA and 162 strikeouts in 74 innings. He was a hot name in the draft and was selected in the 2nd round by the St. Louis Cardinals, receiving a signing bonus of $2,500,000. He immediately impressed in the low minor leagues, striking out 222 batters in 161 innings with an ERA of 2.63. The next year between Double A and Triple A, he was even better with a 2.35 ERA and 194 strikeouts in 134 innings. He didn’t walk a ton of hitters and showed the same confidence he had in High School. There was no reason to think Ankiel wouldn’t be an Ace in the big leagues. He had an impressive rookie season in 2000, going 11-7 with a 3.5 ERA and 194 strikeouts, finishing second in the Rookie of the Year voting. The Cardinals made the playoffs that year and in Ankiel’s first playoff start, something strange happened. After throwing two scoreless innings, he suddenly had a complete meltdown, walking four batters and throwing 5 wild pitches in one inning. It was considered a freak incident and since the Cardinals won the game, no one thought much more of it. That is, until his next start, Game 2 of the NLCS, when 5 of Ankiel’s first 20 pitches went past the catcher. He was removed. In his next appearance, it was more of the same – he faced four batters, walked two and threw two wild pitches. Rick Ankiel had the yips. He returned to the team in 2001, and his problems were not fixed. In 24 innings, he walked 25 batters and threw five wild pitches, causing a demotion to Triple A where he went completely next level, walking 17 batters and throwing 12 wild pitches in 4 1/3rd innings. Later, a left elbow sprain and Tommy John surgery kept him largely out of MLB for the next two years. His career was basically over. Or was it? During 2005 Spring Training, Ankiel announced he was switching to the outfield to be a hitter. He had to start his career all over, going back to Single A, where he showed impressive power, earning a callup to Double A. Unfortunately, he injured his knee in 2006 Spring Training and missed the entire year. Was this the end of his career? Not even close. In 2007 in Triple A, Ankiel crushed 32 home runs, earned a promotion to the big leagues, and smashed a home run in his first big league game as an offensive player. He went on to play 7 years in the big leagues as a hitter, finishing his career with 251 home runs along with some dramatic postseason bombs, such as a game winning home run for Atlanta in the 2010 NLDS against the Giants. For one of the best pitching prospects in the game to get the yips and completely lose his control then turn around and have an extremely strong career as an MLB hitter despite not regularly hitting since High School is absolutely incredible and Rick Ankie’s comeback is one of the greatest in MLB history.

5. Tony Congliaro

Next up is Tony Congliaro, who played mostly for the Boston Red Sox. His pro career started in 1963 when he tore up the Minor Leagues, hitting .363 with 24 home runs. The next year, he was in the Red Sox lineup and hit .290 with 24 home runs followed by a league leading 32 bombs in 1965, becoming the youngest American League player to ever lead the league in home runs. The Red Sox had a superstar on their hands and he made the All Star Team in 1967. He hit his 100th home run at just 22 years old. Then, everything changed during a game on August 18th, 1967 against the California Angels. Facing pitcher Jack Hamilton. A pitch struck Congliaro in the face, causing a linear fracture of his left cheekbone, a dislocated jaw and severe damage to his left retina. He was carried off the field on a stretcher and it was questionable if he would ever play again. Congliario’s eyesight was permanently damaged. He missed the next two seasons entirely. Then, in 1969, 2 and a half years after playing his last game, Congliario attempted a comeback. The Red Sox were happy to give him the opportunity, but didn’t know what to expect. Congliario’s comeback was astonishing as he hit 20 home runs with a .255 average driving 82 runs. The next year, he set a career high in home runs and RBIs with 36 and 116 respectively, while hitting .266. His amazing comeback inspired the Tony Congliaro Award, which has since been awarded to those who overcome adversity. Unfortunately, his eyesight worsened as he entered his thirties and Congliario was forced to retire, but the fact that he came back from such a horrific injury to play four more years, including a career year is truly inspirational.

4. Josh Hamilton

Josh Hamilton after being drafted first overall by the Devil Rays

Coming in at #4 is another #1 overall pick in the MLB Draft, Josh Hamilton. He was an absolute beast in High School, hitting .529 with 13 home runs in 25 games in his Senior Year. He could fly on the basepaths and had a cannon for an arm. The Tampa Bay Devil Rays took him first overall in the 1999 Draft and that year, he hit .312 with 10 home runs in the low minor leagues. The next year, he made the South Atlantic League All Star Team, hitting .302 with 13 home runs in 96 games. Unfortunately, things began in unravel in 2001 after he was involved in a car accident, resulting in injuries to his parents. After landing on the disabled list due to back injuries, Hamilton hung out at tattoo parlors, purchasing two tattoos a day while abusing cocaine and alcohol. He had plenty of cash, with a $3.96 million bonus, and used it to fall deeper and deeper into this new lifestyle. The Devil Rays sent him to the Betty Ford Center, but he checked himself out after just 8 days. In 2003, he failed to show up for a mandatory drug test and was suspended by MLB. He was out of baseball completely now, graduated from cocaine to crack, and lived the life of a junkie, even stealing from his family to feed his addiction. A few times, Hamilton tried to come back to baseball but continued to either relapse or get arrested. Finally, in 2006, a man named Roy Silver hired Hamilton to work at his Baseball Facility in Florida, where he stayed clean and slept on an air mattress in one of the offices. In 2007, after being removed from the 40-man roster, the Cubs claimed Hamilton in the Rule 5 Draft, promptly trading him to the Reds. Part of the stipulation of the Rule 5 Draft is the player must stay on the Major League Roster for an entire season or be returned to the original team, in this case the Devil Rays. Hamilton tore it up in Spring Training in 2007 and earned a spot on the roster, making his big league debut 8 years after being drafted. He hit .292 with 19 home runs, an absolutely incredible feat considering he had barely played the game in the past 5 years. The Reds traded him to the Rangers that offseason, and he became an absolute superstar in Texas, hitting .304 with 32 home runs and an insane 130 runs driven in. He got the attention of every MLB fan at the home run derby that year, smashing a record 28 home runs in the first round. He made 5 straight All Star teams, won an MVP in 2010 and hit four home runs in a single game. He eventually experienced some relapses and injuries, which slowed his career down, but Josh Hamilton had a ridiculous 5-year stretch in Texas, proving that had he never fallen into a lifestyle of drugs & alcohol, Hamilton would have easily had a Hall of Fame career and possibly been one of the greatest to ever play the game. Still, the fact that he came back from depths of darkness he was in to come back and be a superstar MVP player is still incredible and one of the greatest comebacks of all time.

3. Dave Dravecky

Next up is a pitcher named Dave Dravecky. He was a solid left-handed arm in the San Diego Padres rotation for several years in 80’s, making an All Star team in 1983 and maintaining an ERA around 3 every season. Only July 4th, 1987, the San Francisco Giants traded for him, along with Craig Lefferts and Kevin Mitchell, for Mark Grant, Mark Davis and Chris Brown. He pitched well for the Giants, including a shutout performance in the 1987 playoffs against St. Louis. In 1988, he was pitching well with a 3.16 ERA after 7 starts when a cancerous tumor was found in his pitching arm. It was a rare and aggressive tumor known as a desmoid tumor. Unfortunately, it was positioned on his left deltoid muscle, a muscle that is needed by pitchers to even pitch. Doctors would have to remove the tumor and surrounding muscle, a huge portion of his arm, in order to save his life. The surgery was performed in October of 1988 and half of the deltoid muscle was removed. The humerus bone was frozen as well in order to kill all of the cancerous cells. Doctors advised him that he would never pitch again. Dravecky had other plans. His rehab was astonishingly fast, going from not being able to move his arm at all, to lifting 1 lb. Dumbbells, to actually pitching all in a matter of months and by 1989 Dravecky already felt ready to pitch again, although doctors urged him to wait until at least 1990. They feared that the frozen humerus bone could snap if stressed too early. But Dravecky was determined to return that year and he did, returning to the minors in 1989 on rehab assignment, where he threw 3 complete games. There is no possible chance a pitcher would be allowed to complete any games so early in their comeback attempt today, given the circumstances. But in 1989, it happened – he threw three complete games and a shutout with an ERA 1.8, convincing the Giants he was ready for his official comeback game. It occurred on August 10th, 1989, in an amazing day at Candlestick Park. Dravecky pitched 8 innings, defeating the Reds 4-3, despite the doctor’s prediction that he would lose 95% of the use of his left arm. It was one of the most inspiring comebacks of all time and there was absolute magic in the air that day in San Francisco. Unfortunately, it was short-lived as during his next start in Montreal, he felt a strange tingling in his arm, continued to pitch anyway and broke his arm on a pitch. Later, the cancer returned with a vengeance and he had to have his arm amputated. Although he probably should have waited until 1990 to come back as doctors recommended, Dravecky is an absolute amazing athlete with incredible determination and his comeback was one of the most inspiring moments in baseball history. Dave Dravecky continues to travel the country and give motivational speeches today.

2. Eddie Waitkus

Coming in at #2 on my list of the Top 10 Inspirational MLB Comebacks of all time is first baseman Eddie Waitkus. He began his pro career with the Cubs organization in 1939, hitting .326 in the minor leagues and earning his first promotion to the big leagues by 1941. In ‘42, he spent the year in the Minors, hitting .336 for the Los Angeles Angels of the Pacific Coast League. Then, WW2 happened. He was a hero, earning four bronze stars. On one occasional, he left his foxhole, entering into enemy gunfire to save his comrade’s life. He returned to baseball in 1946, after missing three entire seasons due to the war, and hit .304 for the Cubs, eventually becoming an All Star first baseman. But the story doesn’t end there. This was just the first comeback. In June of 1949, Waitkus was hitting well for his new team, the Phillies, with a .306 batting average. But there was a mad fan from Chicago who had worshiped Waitkus named Ruth Ann Steinhagen. She had created a “shrine” to him with hundreds of photos and newspaper clippings. Steinhagen even set a plate for him at the dinner table. After he left to play for the Phillies, she fantasized about killing him. When the Phillies came to Chicago for a series against the Cubs, she checked into the same hotel he was staying in and had the bellboy give him a note urging him to see her for some important information that he would want to know. When he arrived at her room, she shot him with a .22 caliber rifle. There are some disputes over what, if anything, was said, but according to Watkus’s friend and roommate, Waitkus told him that she said “If I can’t have you, nobody else can.” The bullet barely missed his heart and during the operation, he almost died several times. Incredibly, Waitkus recovered and returned in 1950 and played 6 more years in the Majors. He hit .289 in 1951 and .291 in ‘53. His story was part of the inspiration for the film “The Natural.” Eddie Waitkus makes #2 of this list because he not only made an amazing comeback from being a war hero, but he also came back from being shot and nearly killed by an insane fan.

1. Lou Brissie

Lou Brissie with his baseball card

My #1 most inspirational comeback in MLB history goes to former MLB pitcher Lou Brissie. Brissie was born in Anderson, South Carolina in 1924 and grew up in the town of Ware Shoals, a location where the most popular baseball was played in local textile leagues. Brissie’s career began in 1940 on the Ware Shoals baseball team. He was a talented young pitcher who, as a dominating lefty at 6’4”, caught the attention of Philadelphia A’s manger Connie Mack in 1941. He signed with the Athletics on 1941 with the understanding that he would pitch for three years in college and then begin his professional career. Unfortunately, before he could complete his college career, war broke out and he joined the United States Army. Before going off to war, he was stationed at Camp Croft in South Carolina. One day on leave, he rejoined the War Shoals team for a game and struck out 22 batters. By 1943 he had been deployed to Italy, and his unit, the 88th Infantry Division, saw a lot of action and suffered many casualties. After 14 months fighting, in December of 1944, his unit came under heavy artillery fire. At least 12 men were killed in the attack and one explosion went off near Brissie, whose last memory before falling unconscious was of himself half in and half out of water with one foot severely damaged and the other completely missing. He was left for dead and found several hours later, with his left tibia and shinbone shattered into 30 pieces. Doctors informed him the leg would need to be amputated but Brissie persuaded them to try and save it so he could eventually play ball again. He had 23 surgeries and 40 blood transfusions performed over 2 years, reconstructing his leg with wire. Connie Mack heard about the severity of the injury and wrote to Brissie, saying that his duty was to to get well and whenever he was ready to play, Mack would make sure he got the opportunity. “That meant an awful lot to me,” said Brissie. “It was a tremendous motivator.” Eventually, after a year of rehab, he could walk with a cane. In 1945 as Shibe Park, he held a workout for Connie Mack, trying to pitch on crutches. Mack later said, “I’ll never forget how he looked last summer, he had just undergone an operation and was about to undergo another one. He was on crutches and I thought, ‘Poor boy. He’ll never be able to pitch again.’” For another year, he kept rehabbing and pushing through pain to learn how to pitch again. Finally, in 1947, 6 years after he first signed with the A’s, Connie Mack gave him the opportunity he promised. He was sent to A Ball and was amazing, going 23-5 with a 1.91 ERA and 278 strikeouts. After the Minor League season, he was promoted. Against all odds, Lou Brissie made it to the big leagues. In 1948, he went 14-10 with a 4.13 ERA, kicking off a 7 year Major League career. After retirement he confirmed that he pitched through severe pain every game. His career ERA in a respectable 4.17 and there’s no telling how good he would have been had the injury never occurred. But what he did was even more impressive and is #1 on today’s list as the most inspirational comeback in baseball history.

And that does it for today’s article on the most inspirational comebacks in MLB history. There are many others I’m sure I missed so please feel free to share them in the comments section below. Thank you so much for checking out the blog and remember, as Lou Brissie once said, “If someone tells you that you cannot climb the mountain, you set out and find a way to do it.”